New weapon types study - Knuckles, Polearms, Spears, Relics, and more - Page 2 — Guild Wars 2 Forums
Home Professions

New weapon types study - Knuckles, Polearms, Spears, Relics, and more

2>

Comments

  • Lonami.2987Lonami.2987 Member ✭✭✭✭
    edited October 11, 2018

    The original idea feels somewhat outdated, and I have changed a few opinions since I posted it, in part thanks to everyone contributing. So I guess it's time for an update!

    Here's my new take, I'm a bit less rigid with the animation department this time, and I'm going harder for the cool factor too. I still think this set is fairly viable, and includes more variety, with more potential for originality. Hope you like it!

    New weapons

    These are my 6 ideal weapons, for a total of 22.

    • Fists: One-handed, can be wielded in one hand or both. They replace active glove skins when wielded.
    • Spear: One-handed, can be wielded in one hand or both. Mostly ranged usage.
    • Bell: Off-hand. Percussion instrument, played to vibrate ambient magic. Connected to geomancy.
    • Vial: Off-hand. Container of liquid which can be drunk, spilled, or thrown. Includes bottles of wine, magic potions, steins of beer, barrels, and more.
    • Polearm: Two-handed. Includes greataxes, scythes, halberds, longspears, and more.
    • Relic: Two-handed. Magical artifact inspired by the old guardian tomes. Floats on the left hand, while you cast with the right hand. Includes books of magic, astrolabes, cauldrons, musical instruments, ashes, tablets, and more.

    Each core profession would unlock two of the above for free, without any specialization requirements. Further unlocks would become possible through elite specializations. These core unlocks would be as follows:

    • Elementalist: Bell, Relic.
    • Mesmer: Vial, Relic.
    • Necromancer: Bell, Polearm.
    • Engineer: Fists, Vial.
    • Ranger: Spear, Bell.
    • Thief: Fists, Spear.
    • Guardian: Spear, Relic.
    • Revenant: Fists, Polearm.
    • Warrior: Vial, Polearm.

    Underwater weapons

    You might have noticed I didn't count the 3 underwater weapons when counting above. That's because I'm merging them with some of the ground weapons. They would remain separate equipment-wise, but use the same skin pool.

    • Harpoon (old spear) merges with polearm.
    • Speargun (old harpoon gun) merges with rifle.
    • Trident merges with staff.

    You would still need to craft them separately, so for example, you wouldn't be able to use a trident as a staff. This merge only covers skins, effectively removing underwater weapons from the wardrobe.

    Updates to old weapons

    Other potential new weapons would be included inside the existing types. Few examples:

    • Axes now include chakrams, boomerangs, and other thrown blades.
    • Daggers now include fans.
    • Maces now include one-handed hammers.
    • Rifles now include crossbows.
    • Shortbows now include slingshots.

    I feel like this model is much more solid than my previous idea, and also includes more exciting new options.

    Bonus: New legendary weapons

    Because, why not?

    • Fists: Steam-powered mecha-hands, the wrists rotate in combat like a drill.
    • Spear: GW1's Voltaic Spears, this time with more lightning.
    • Bell: Instead of a handheld bell, a floating familiar carries a Canthan jade tower bell by your side, and you pull the rope to play it. Includes musical instrument toy version.
    • Vial: A whole barrel of the legendary norn beer, Bear's Brown Ale. Your character occasionally makes drunk jokes. Frost effect, plus tiny pink elephants appear around you.
    • Polearm: Dual-bladed djinn elemental scythe, effects changing from fire to ice. Aura and footsteps change their effects as well, synchronized with the weapon.
    • Relic: Cauldron of Cataclysm, a handheld replica of the artifact behind the Searing of Ascalon.

    @RobbyT.1925 said:
    Personally, I'd rather see the addition of more skills to the current weapons. one of the things that made GW1 great was the fact that you could have two characters that had the same two classes, same weapons, but two entirely different builds. It made each character feel unique, whereas now, GW2 has been going strong for ~6 years and every Ranger with a short bow plays the exact same way. I'd like to see more weapons, but I'd like to see the addition of more skills on the current weapons first. Perhaps LW season 4 or 5 will see either of these two come to fruition?

    Yeah, that's something that would be nice, but it should come through traits. New elite specializations should have new weapons they couldn't use before.

  • hugo.4705hugo.4705 Member ✭✭✭✭
    edited October 11, 2018

    I'm up for CROSSBOW engineer since 2012. I have so few weapons choices and I hate kits. If it's done RIGHT it can be an awesome weapon with stunning mechanics.
    Even have some skills icons!
    1.Charged bullet, 2.Arrow volley, 3.special trick, 4.shock-wave, 5. Ionized shot (Shot at others to deploy a protective, regenerative shield)...
    Link with profession? -Power + Support in same time. Crossbow can be used to launch arrows but some flasks or devices too.
    Can be used at RANGE / CLOSE COMBAT.

    EDIT: NO FISTS. Very fan of vials, but fists have 0 to do with engineer: A class with main theme "Mechanics/technologies"
    Masters of mechanical mayhem, engineers love to tinker with explosives, elixirs, and all manner of hazardous gadgets. They can take control of an area by placing turrets, support their allies with alchemic weaponry, or lay waste to foes with a wide array of mines, bombs, and grenades. Ref: WIKI

    Proof: core=kits, exp1=mechanic exp2=Sci-Fi shooter, using solar energy. So in sum up, "Engineering complexity/Intelligence" don't see an engineer fighting with fists, that's against his nature. Even reinforced/ electrified ones like knuckles....

    Shiny links, take a look!
    ->Ideas: Housing , Designing a new lounge , New GameMode
    ->Project: ASURAN/PRIMORDIUS EXPANSION available on WIKI.
    ->NEW: Crucible of Eternity path 4: Legacy on WIKI
    ->NEW Asurapedia

  • Catchyfx.5768Catchyfx.5768 Member ✭✭✭

    If any go with "greataxe"
    We got
    Mace->Hammer
    Sword->greatsword
    axe-> :-(

    Jokaurene

  • hugo.4705hugo.4705 Member ✭✭✭✭
    edited October 11, 2018

    Currently, you can somehow class weapons:
    -Mace-like: Hammer, Mace
    -Sword-like: Sword, Greatsword, Spear, Trident
    -Magical-stuff: Focus, Scepter, Warhorn
    -Gun-like: Rifle,Pistols,Harpoon-gun
    -Bows: Shortbow, Longbow
    -Protection: Torch, Shield
    -Berserk: Axe

    Shiny links, take a look!
    ->Ideas: Housing , Designing a new lounge , New GameMode
    ->Project: ASURAN/PRIMORDIUS EXPANSION available on WIKI.
    ->NEW: Crucible of Eternity path 4: Legacy on WIKI
    ->NEW Asurapedia

  • ZDragon.3046ZDragon.3046 Member ✭✭✭✭
    edited October 12, 2018

    I don't think anet has time or resources to be wasting making purely new weapon base types.

    Everyone is screaming great axe but realistically that wont happen.
    I think the best we can hope for would be new e specs that maybe give weapon skins, profession mechanic abilities, or utility skills similar to new weapons you are looking at but visually i doubt we will see new weapon types as base weapons.

    Like no one here said "cannon" as a weapon but holosmith has a cannon for its elite skill
    Reaper has a scythe for its shroud attacks
    Engi and its tool kits which contain different weapons out of the norm.

    I think we can expect to possibly see more things like the above on other elite specs in the future.
    If warrior gets a great axe it will likely be locked behind some mechanic on its profession bar or something and coded with the script of great sword / hammer despite it looking like a great axe.

    Because anet started this path so far its ideally better if they hold to it and build weapons into profession elite specs rather than trying to make a new weapon type that can fit across several professions. Take that new weapon you want and make it into a skill or several skills, or transform ability that can easily be represented or coded with an existing base weapon as its frame.

    We are more likely to see things like.

    Warrior Elite spec : Barbarian
    First trait
    F1 Primal Instinct - Lose access to standard burst attacks and gain access to "Barbaric Fury"
    Barbaric Fury Use adrenaline to push your inner strength and draw your 'Great Axe' gaining new skills and abilities, Adrenaline drains over time.

    Necro possibly getting kits that equip vials or something
    Rangers with a execution style spear throwing elite's / utilities

    Again these are just made up examples of what i think we are likely to see something similar to over just the creation of new weapons. I feel like this is anets best way of doing this without having to over invest int dozens of new weapon skins, renders, skills, not to mention adding 1 new weapon means they have to add several new weapons because obviously not every profession will get access to just that 1 weapon if only 1 got added. Its overall alot more work and thus alot more unlikely.

  • Opopanax.1803Opopanax.1803 Member ✭✭✭✭

    I wonder if crossbow could use rifle animations to save dev time? It would use a lot of the same aiming / trigger pulling

  • hugo.4705hugo.4705 Member ✭✭✭✭
    edited October 13, 2018

    @Opopanax.1803 said:
    I wonder if crossbow could use rifle animations to save dev time? It would use a lot of the same aiming / trigger pulling

    Yeah sure, but imo would be closer to bows. You can put whatever you want on it, but we will always have a bell trajectory. Also having a reduced recharge time compared to rifle.

    The first question to ask ourselves is:
    Two-handed or not? If two, we can use bow animation. A smoke cloud at the end of the crossbow is sufficient, for the rest attacks have to be simply coppied from grenades, bows, etc...

    Shiny links, take a look!
    ->Ideas: Housing , Designing a new lounge , New GameMode
    ->Project: ASURAN/PRIMORDIUS EXPANSION available on WIKI.
    ->NEW: Crucible of Eternity path 4: Legacy on WIKI
    ->NEW Asurapedia

  • I wanna see elite specs change the skills on current weapons. Because thief-assassins needs to have a daggers as deadly weapons and not as whacking sticks.

  • Jack Redline.5379Jack Redline.5379 Member ✭✭✭✭

    I would like the fists for Thief but not in the next Expansion. Maybe later. I mean it would be really nice to smack the hell out of your enemies xD Also DD could be that. I dont know why we had to have Staff. It could be done with kicks and punches like a NINJA like espec would do it. But okay i am fine with this

  • Obtena.7952Obtena.7952 Member ✭✭✭✭

    It's weird this was a disappointment to the OP ... we didn't get them in HoT and Anet made no announcement we would see new ones in PoF.

    I wouldn't mind more but to be frank, it's just a label ... as long as at least one weapon exists for each class to expand into, I have little faith Anet would put much effort into new ones.

    If I were Anet, my biggest problem is that you couldn't make just one new weapon because that would be very dissatisfying to the classes that wouldn't get that weapon. We would need at least 2 or 3 and even then, that wouldn't guarantee a new weapon for a new espec.

    Abuse from people that tell you how to play is not a reason to change a class in a game that is designed and works to allow you to play how you want.

  • Arcaedus.7290Arcaedus.7290 Member ✭✭✭✭

    On this same note, I made a post in general discussion about implementing spears or underwater weapons as land weapons.

    It could be viable, it could be done in such a way to minimize production costs and it could be monetized. I definitely agree with OP that some new weapons in the game would be a welcome addition.

    I agree with the OP here - new weapons would be fun, and interesting. Personally I'd love them to be included and I know most of the community either wants new weapons or is ambivalent about the issue. This should have been done with PoF. It's not too late, and it should be done sooner rather than later if Anet cares to do it at all because we're getting to a point where it may result in a fairness issue over who gets which weapons unless they do something totally out there, like 9 unique weapons for the final expac.

    @Obtena.7952 said:

    If I were Anet, my biggest problem is that you couldn't make just one new weapon because that would be very dissatisfying to the classes that wouldn't get that weapon. We would need at least 2 or 3 and even then, that wouldn't guarantee a new weapon for a new espec.

    Addressing your last point here: You pose a good argument and it's one of the key things someone should address when proposing new weapons be added to the game. There are multiple ways to solve this problem if Anet really wanted to though:

    • Create three-four new weapon types. Within 3 expacs, every class would have gained access to at least one of the new weapons.
    • Create three new weapon types. Every single new elite spec would get one of the three weapons in the next expac (this could be done for the final expac).
    • Create 9 new weapon types and each new elite spec gets one. Similar to previous option, much more novel but likely more tedious for the devs.
    • Create an achievement/crafting-based system of modification, where the new weapon types are obtained by attaching a crafted/earned piece to an already existing weapon (for example, you attach a spearhead to any exotic, ascended or legendary staff you have, and it turns into a spear of equal grade keeping the same stats, sigils, infusions). Advantage here is that each of the 9 professions could receive their own unique weapon-type. Disadvantage is tedium for the devs to develop such a system.
  • I dig it,
    Blow gun thief could be sweet, but deadeye already has the stealthy range covered

  • InsaneQR.7412InsaneQR.7412 Member ✭✭✭✭
    edited November 13, 2018

    @Klowdy.3126 said:
    Tomes are now abilities, used by two classes. They aren't going to turn them into something that is bought/dropped after implementing them as spells, especially since one is an elite spec.

    What other profession uses tomes except firebrand—guardian?
    Thats one profession as far as i see.

  • Lonami.2987Lonami.2987 Member ✭✭✭✭

    @DragonSlayer.1087 said:
    I wanna see elite specs change the skills on current weapons. Because thief-assassins needs to have a daggers as deadly weapons and not as whacking sticks.

    I think I'd rather redesign core weapons. If the skills are bad, why fix them through elite specializations, when you could just update them for core?

    I feel like many ranger weapon skills are terrible, for example.

    @Obtena.7952 said:
    It's weird this was a disappointment to the OP ... we didn't get them in HoT and Anet made no announcement we would see new ones in PoF.

    I wouldn't mind more but to be frank, it's just a label ... as long as at least one weapon exists for each class to expand into, I have little faith Anet would put much effort into new ones.

    If I were Anet, my biggest problem is that you couldn't make just one new weapon because that would be very dissatisfying to the classes that wouldn't get that weapon. We would need at least 2 or 3 and even then, that wouldn't guarantee a new weapon for a new espec.

    That's already covered in the post above, just unlock 2 new weapon types for every core profession for free, and unlock the rest through elite specializations.

    @Arcaedus.7290 said:
    On this same note, I made a post in general discussion about implementing spears or underwater weapons as land weapons.

    It could be viable, it could be done in such a way to minimize production costs and it could be monetized. I definitely agree with OP that some new weapons in the game would be a welcome addition.

    I agree with the OP here - new weapons would be fun, and interesting. Personally I'd love them to be included and I know most of the community either wants new weapons or is ambivalent about the issue. This should have been done with PoF. It's not too late, and it should be done sooner rather than later if Anet cares to do it at all because we're getting to a point where it may result in a fairness issue over who gets which weapons unless they do something totally out there, like 9 unique weapons for the final expac.

    @Obtena.7952 said:

    If I were Anet, my biggest problem is that you couldn't make just one new weapon because that would be very dissatisfying to the classes that wouldn't get that weapon. We would need at least 2 or 3 and even then, that wouldn't guarantee a new weapon for a new espec.

    Addressing your last point here: You pose a good argument and it's one of the key things someone should address when proposing new weapons be added to the game. There are multiple ways to solve this problem if Anet really wanted to though:

    • Create three-four new weapon types. Within 3 expacs, every class would have gained access to at least one of the new weapons.
    • Create three new weapon types. Every single new elite spec would get one of the three weapons in the next expac (this could be done for the final expac).
    • Create 9 new weapon types and each new elite spec gets one. Similar to previous option, much more novel but likely more tedious for the devs.
    • Create an achievement/crafting-based system of modification, where the new weapon types are obtained by attaching a crafted/earned piece to an already existing weapon (for example, you attach a spearhead to any exotic, ascended or legendary staff you have, and it turns into a spear of equal grade keeping the same stats, sigils, infusions). Advantage here is that each of the 9 professions could receive their own unique weapon-type. Disadvantage is tedium for the devs to develop such a system.

    I don't think every profession needs to be able to use every new weapon. I mean, in my new suggestions above there's stuff like a relic, which is a two-handed magical artifact. The likes of engineer, thief, and warrior have no business being able to use something like that.

    The key should be to add enough new weapons so that everyone gets their own share.

    @InsaneQR.7412 said:

    @Klowdy.3126 said:
    Tomes are now abilities, used by two classes. They aren't going to turn them into something that is bought/dropped after implementing them as spells, especially since one is an elite spec.

    What other profession uses tomes except firebrand—guardian?
    Thats one profession as far as i see.

    And even then, guardian doesn't really use tomes. Yeah, the virtue skills are called tomes, but they don't summon actual tomes, only some flying paper pages. The original "tome kit" was removed years ago, and it didn't came back with the firebrand, much to my dismay.

    But then again, this could be a new opportunity for something bigger, like a new weapon type, which I like far more than actual tome kits.

  • Leo G.4501Leo G.4501 Member ✭✭✭✭

    @Klowdy.3126 said:

    @Conncept.7638 said:
    I cannot believe you don't have tomes on the first priority list.

    • Like the underwater weapons, they are, or were, already in game.
    • As a magic weapon, it would be more particle effect driven, requiring way less animation work than any martial weapon.
    • There are no caster weapons left. The game only launched with three, already available to every caster profession. There is so much design space left for more traditional spellcasting, but no magic weapons to place traditional spellcasting skills on.
    • And finally, we already have a profession that should have had it, the axe makes absolutely no sense for the firebrand and was clearly a tacked on compromise on the firebrands aesthetic and theme. We have a sophisticated mystical librarian and lorekeeper, wielding the most primitive, brutish, barbaric weapon in the game.

    Tomes are now abilities, used by two classes. They aren't going to turn them into something that is bought/dropped after implementing them as spells, especially since one is an elite spec.

    "I'm using a tome in order to use my tomes more effectively...in my tome build...with tomes"

    No.

    Lucky for you, mate, Firebrand doesn't even use tomes...they use pages!

  • Leo G.4501Leo G.4501 Member ✭✭✭✭

    @Lonami.2987 said:
    In retrospective, I wish they had been their own weapon type, but it's clear the focus type was designed to cover them and many other things, something I believe it's a mistake. I can't even tell what the hell 80% of the foci skins are, they're just ugly things with no point whatsoever. They should have been books, orbs, scrolls, and stuff like that, instead of random junk. Really bad design decision with foci skins all around, but too late to fix that, I guess.

    If it was in my hands, I would redesign the whole focus category and make them all book skins and such, or make sure new skins are actually decent instead of those weird hand-weapon things, but I'm not sure the "purpose" of books/tomes would be different from that of foci, thus me not splitting them in two.

    Hopefully, this will be the case now we got custom animations for the new legendary focus, but I don't know.

    Nah, no point. Unless you like pissing people off just for your own OCD, you're better off just making a new class of weapon focused on something coherent enough and just accept the mistake of the focus weapon and let those players that enjoy it as is have it. You can still have, for example, an orb weapon category along with the focus category if you make them mechanically and aesthetically different.

  • MyPuppy.8970MyPuppy.8970 Member ✭✭✭✭

    A whip. A thorny spiky whip. And stilettos. And maybe a rope too.

  • @Lonami.2987 said:

    @DragonSlayer.1087 said:
    I wanna see elite specs change the skills on current weapons. Because thief-assassins needs to have a daggers as deadly weapons and not as whacking sticks.

    I think I'd rather redesign core weapons. If the skills are bad, why fix them through elite specializations, when you could just update them for core?

    The reason I said that is because core weapons are affected by elite specs. For example, Daggers. When they modified the DE, it turned the D/D into a gimmick build, which IF nerfed at some point will affect core thieves. Hence, why I wish the next elite specs would have their own skill sets for 'core weapons' making them independent from balancing.

  • Arcaedus.7290Arcaedus.7290 Member ✭✭✭✭

    @Lonami.2987 said:

    I don't think every profession needs to be able to use every new weapon. I mean, in my new suggestions above there's stuff like a relic, which is a two-handed magical artifact. The likes of engineer, thief, and warrior have no business being able to use something like that.

    Right, and this is what I was saying with my first bullet point. What I was saying with later bullet points is that if Anet so wanted, every class could gain access to each of the new weapon types. No matter what though, if new weapon types get introduced, it would have to be 3+ new weapon types, and for fairness, every class would have to get access to at least one of the weapon-types before the game's final expansion

  • I think adapting Spears onto land would be the best direction for this franchise to go in terms of introducing new weapon.

    The fact we never got land spears at launch is just mind-baffling. Not only are Spears a Guild Wars tradition, being one of the most beloved weapon types in the first game, but it's an insanely popular fantasy weapon in general.

    This game is in desperate need of new weapons, and I'm not talking elite specs. We need new weapons for the core classes in general.

    Some ideas:

    Warrior: SPEARGUN. A ranged support weapon revolving around CC and mobility. Utilized similarly to a freaking HOOKSHOT! Speargun #5 tethers to yourself to foe, immobilizing them and applying periodic cripple or vulnerability. Activating the flipover skills will cause Speargun #5 to pull your foe from 900 range, similar to DH #F1. Speargun #4 could be a mobility which pulls you to the foe along with stunning them for a second.

    Necromancer: Spear. A condi alternative to Scepter, used as a melee weapon to cleave multiple targets.

    Engineer: Speargun. A ranged power DPS weapon which shoots explosive harpoons at foes. (This is intended to be an Engineer's ranged power dps, since Rifle is mid-range shotgun, and Mortar/grenades are ground target hell...)

  • I believe that anet (unconfirmed) has stated that they won't shy away from reusing weapons if needed. Things like taking the staff, and turning it into a spear weapon with certain animations for the e-spec. Or a scythe. That can certainly be done and doesn't require the backload involved with creating a new weapon.

    Weapons are given new skill-sets, that kind of thing.

    I can definitely see that happening.

    Do you want a balanced GW2? Then you are obliged to unironically agree with this suggestion!

  • Arcaedus.7290Arcaedus.7290 Member ✭✭✭✭

    @Aplethoraof.2643 said:
    I believe that anet (unconfirmed) has stated that they won't shy away from reusing weapons if needed. Things like taking the staff, and turning it into a spear weapon with certain animations for the e-spec. Or a scythe. That can certainly be done and doesn't require the backload involved with creating a new weapon.

    Weapons are given new skill-sets, that kind of thing.

    I can definitely see that happening.

    I get what you're saying, but with the tiny bit of programming knowledge I do have, let me make this argument:

    It would not be that much more work (than just reusing current weapons) to have a few "new" weapon types as long as they're attached to elite specializations.

    Every time a new elite spec gets created, a "new weapon" in some sense is also created. Before PoF, mesmer with axe did not exist, so that had to be newly created, though not entirely from scratch: there already exists a model of the player character rigged with axe, so all that had to be done was enable that rig on mesmer, and reuse assets such as basic axe swing/throw animations that warrior already has, plus design some new ones (Lingering Thoughts animation is unique) and some unique visual effects (purple shockwaves and blurs and whatnot) to compliment the mesmer class + add flavor to the skills and elite spec.

    But quite possibly the best example of this is staff being used as a melee weapon on daredevil/revenant. This is effectively an entirely new weapon being created. A slightly new rig had to be made for staff being used as a melee weapon which is apparent by how they hold staff like a hammer (melee weapon) as opposed to every other class holding staff like a mage would. Many basic striking and swinging animations were also freshly designed (the unique auto attack they both share is a good example), but also many animations were reused. Rev staff 2 (both hits) and daredevil staff 4 are essentially just warrior/guardian hammer swing animations.

    What I'm arguing is they could introduce new weapon-types by the same process they used to design staff on daredevil and revenant. Don't get me wrong, doing this would definitely be more difficult, but I don't think it would be that much more difficult than their current model of giving new elite specs one of the current weapons. There are other challenges obviously, mainly with having to write code for a new weapon-type ID in the system (marketplace/trading, achievements, crafting, vendors/merchants) which will take time but can arguably be seen as a one-time investment.

    Overall, I think this is something that while only maybe economically viable for Anet (something for them to decide) it's well within the developers' capabilities. They're very talented and if they wanted to, they'd implement new weapons.

  • Lonami.2987Lonami.2987 Member ✭✭✭✭
    edited August 3, 2019

    @Lonami.2987 said:
    The original idea feels somewhat outdated, and I have changed a few opinions since I posted it, in part thanks to everyone contributing. So I guess it's time for an update!

    Here's my new take, I'm a bit less rigid with the animation department this time, and I'm going harder for the cool factor too. I still think this set is fairly viable, and includes more variety, with more potential for originality. Hope you like it!

    New weapons

    These are my 6 ideal weapons, for a total of 22.

    • Fists: One-handed, can be wielded in one hand or both. They replace active glove skins when wielded.
    • Spear: One-handed, can be wielded in one hand or both. Mostly ranged usage.
    • Bell: Off-hand. Percussion instrument, played to vibrate ambient magic. Connected to geomancy.
    • Vial: Off-hand. Container of liquid which can be drunk, spilled, or thrown. Includes bottles of wine, magic potions, steins of beer, barrels, and more.
    • Polearm: Two-handed. Includes greataxes, scythes, halberds, longspears, and more.
    • Relic: Two-handed. Magical artifact inspired by the old guardian tomes. Floats on the left hand, while you cast with the right hand. Includes books of magic, astrolabes, cauldrons, musical instruments, ashes, tablets, and more.

    Each core profession would unlock two of the above for free, without any specialization requirements. Further unlocks would become possible through elite specializations. These core unlocks would be as follows:

    • Elementalist: Bell, Relic.
    • Mesmer: Vial, Relic.
    • Necromancer: Bell, Polearm.
    • Engineer: Fists, Vial.
    • Ranger: Spear, Bell.
    • Thief: Fists, Spear.
    • Guardian: Spear, Relic.
    • Revenant: Fists, Polearm.
    • Warrior: Vial, Polearm.

    Underwater weapons

    You might have noticed I didn't count the 3 underwater weapons when counting above. That's because I'm merging them with some of the ground weapons. They would remain separate equipment-wise, but use the same skin pool.

    • Harpoon (old spear) merges with polearm.
    • Speargun (old harpoon gun) merges with rifle.
    • Trident merges with staff.

    You would still need to craft them separately, so for example, you wouldn't be able to use a trident as a staff. This merge only covers skins, effectively removing underwater weapons from the wardrobe.

    Updates to old weapons

    Other potential new weapons would be included inside the existing types. Few examples:

    • Axes now include chakrams, boomerangs, and other thrown blades.
    • Daggers now include fans.
    • Maces now include one-handed hammers.
    • Rifles now include crossbows.
    • Shortbows now include slingshots.

    I feel like this model is much more solid than my previous idea, and also includes more exciting new options.

    Bonus: New legendary weapons

    Because, why not?

    • Fists: Steam-powered mecha-hands, the wrists rotate in combat like a drill.
    • Spear: GW1's Voltaic Spears, this time with more lightning.
    • Bell: Instead of a handheld bell, a floating familiar carries a Canthan jade tower bell by your side, and you pull the rope to play it. Includes musical instrument toy version.
    • Vial: A whole barrel of the legendary norn beer, Bear's Brown Ale. Your character occasionally makes drunk jokes. Frost effect, plus tiny pink elephants appear around you.
    • Polearm: Dual-bladed djinn elemental scythe, effects changing from fire to ice. Aura and footsteps change their effects as well, synchronized with the weapon.
    • Relic: Cauldron of Cataclysm, a handheld replica of the artifact behind the Searing of Ascalon.

    Time for another update:

    New weapons

    These are my 4 ideal weapons, for a total of 20.

    • Satchel: One-handed, can be wielded in one hand or both. Thrown, inspired by the Grenade Satchel of the engineer.
    • Spear: One-handed, can be wielded in one hand or both. Melee and thrown.
    • Battlegloves: Two-handed. They replace active glove skins when wielded. Melee and ranged.
    • Polearm: Two-handed. Includes greataxes, scythes, halberds, longspears, and more. Melee.

    Each core profession would unlock one or two of the above for free, without any specialization requirements. Further unlocks would become possible through elite specializations. These core unlocks would be as follows:

    • Elementalist: Battlegloves.
    • Mesmer: Satchel.
    • Necromancer: Polearm.
    • Engineer: Satchel, Battlegloves.
    • Ranger: Spear.
    • Thief: Satchel, Battlegloves.
    • Guardian: Spear.
    • Revenant: Polearm.
    • Warrior: Spear, Polearm.

    I feel like these four are more solid than the six I had before. Few design notes:

    • Off-hand weapons weren't engaging enough, and feel a bit like filler, so I just removed them. Both the Vial and the Bell could return as weapon kits, slot skills, bundles, or just animations.
    • Satchel gives us more thrown options, and allows grenade-like gameplay to expand outside engineer. I consider it an evolution of the Vial. It would replace the Grenade Kit on the engineer.
    • Fists were renamed to Battlegloves, and reclassified as two-handed. Figured out the weapon skills would feel better if they used both hands for everything. They would be usable for both melee combat and casting magical ranged attacks.
    • Relic is gone, since it felt a bit clunky. Still has potential as a weapon kit profession mechanic, with dedicated skins.
    • Spear and Polearm were already solid enough, so they stay the same.

    Bonus: Elite specialization ideas

    Few elite specialization ideas, using both new and repurposed weapon types:

    • Elementalist - Dervish: Polearm (scythe skin).
    • Mesmer - Dreamcharmer: Dagger (fan skin).
    • Necromancer - Apothecary: Satchel (plague bomb skin).
    • Ranger - Beastlord: Polearm (greataxe skin).
    • Thief - Bladewind: Axe (boomerang skin).
    • Guardian - Paragon: Polearm (two-handed spear skin).
    • Revenant - Hierophant: Battlegloves (Flame Legion Shaman skin).
    • Warrior - Gladiator: Staff (trident skin).

    @Leo G.4501 said:

    @Klowdy.3126 said:

    @Conncept.7638 said:
    I cannot believe you don't have tomes on the first priority list.

    • Like the underwater weapons, they are, or were, already in game.
    • As a magic weapon, it would be more particle effect driven, requiring way less animation work than any martial weapon.
    • There are no caster weapons left. The game only launched with three, already available to every caster profession. There is so much design space left for more traditional spellcasting, but no magic weapons to place traditional spellcasting skills on.
    • And finally, we already have a profession that should have had it, the axe makes absolutely no sense for the firebrand and was clearly a tacked on compromise on the firebrands aesthetic and theme. We have a sophisticated mystical librarian and lorekeeper, wielding the most primitive, brutish, barbaric weapon in the game.

    Tomes are now abilities, used by two classes. They aren't going to turn them into something that is bought/dropped after implementing them as spells, especially since one is an elite spec.

    "I'm using a tome in order to use my tomes more effectively...in my tome build...with tomes"

    No.

    Lucky for you, mate, Firebrand doesn't even use tomes...they use pages!

    I'm still salty about that. Hope firebrand is redesigned to use actual tomes some day, specially considering Suriel and other NPCs still use the old visuals.

    @Aplethoraof.2643 said:
    I believe that anet (unconfirmed) has stated that they won't shy away from reusing weapons if needed. Things like taking the staff, and turning it into a spear weapon with certain animations for the e-spec. Or a scythe. That can certainly be done and doesn't require the backload involved with creating a new weapon.

    Weapons are given new skill-sets, that kind of thing.

    I can definitely see that happening.

    That's fine, and I actually support it, but we need new actual weapons too. Recycling is good, but it should be done with moderation. Note that new weapons can coexist with old weapons too, while "reworked classic weapons" can't. By your model, a necromancer wouldn't be able to wield a staff and a scythe at the same time, and that's kinda restrictive.

  • Lonami.2987Lonami.2987 Member ✭✭✭✭
    edited July 3, 2020

    @Lonami.2987 said:

    @Lonami.2987 said:
    The original idea feels somewhat outdated, and I have changed a few opinions since I posted it, in part thanks to everyone contributing. So I guess it's time for an update!

    Here's my new take, I'm a bit less rigid with the animation department this time, and I'm going harder for the cool factor too. I still think this set is fairly viable, and includes more variety, with more potential for originality. Hope you like it!

    New weapons

    These are my 6 ideal weapons, for a total of 22.

    • Fists: One-handed, can be wielded in one hand or both. They replace active glove skins when wielded.
    • Spear: One-handed, can be wielded in one hand or both. Mostly ranged usage.
    • Bell: Off-hand. Percussion instrument, played to vibrate ambient magic. Connected to geomancy.
    • Vial: Off-hand. Container of liquid which can be drunk, spilled, or thrown. Includes bottles of wine, magic potions, steins of beer, barrels, and more.
    • Polearm: Two-handed. Includes greataxes, scythes, halberds, longspears, and more.
    • Relic: Two-handed. Magical artifact inspired by the old guardian tomes. Floats on the left hand, while you cast with the right hand. Includes books of magic, astrolabes, cauldrons, musical instruments, ashes, tablets, and more.

    Each core profession would unlock two of the above for free, without any specialization requirements. Further unlocks would become possible through elite specializations. These core unlocks would be as follows:

    • Elementalist: Bell, Relic.
    • Mesmer: Vial, Relic.
    • Necromancer: Bell, Polearm.
    • Engineer: Fists, Vial.
    • Ranger: Spear, Bell.
    • Thief: Fists, Spear.
    • Guardian: Spear, Relic.
    • Revenant: Fists, Polearm.
    • Warrior: Vial, Polearm.

    Underwater weapons

    You might have noticed I didn't count the 3 underwater weapons when counting above. That's because I'm merging them with some of the ground weapons. They would remain separate equipment-wise, but use the same skin pool.

    • Harpoon (old spear) merges with polearm.
    • Speargun (old harpoon gun) merges with rifle.
    • Trident merges with staff.

    You would still need to craft them separately, so for example, you wouldn't be able to use a trident as a staff. This merge only covers skins, effectively removing underwater weapons from the wardrobe.

    Updates to old weapons

    Other potential new weapons would be included inside the existing types. Few examples:

    • Axes now include chakrams, boomerangs, and other thrown blades.
    • Daggers now include fans.
    • Maces now include one-handed hammers.
    • Rifles now include crossbows.
    • Shortbows now include slingshots.

    I feel like this model is much more solid than my previous idea, and also includes more exciting new options.

    Bonus: New legendary weapons

    Because, why not?

    • Fists: Steam-powered mecha-hands, the wrists rotate in combat like a drill.
    • Spear: GW1's Voltaic Spears, this time with more lightning.
    • Bell: Instead of a handheld bell, a floating familiar carries a Canthan jade tower bell by your side, and you pull the rope to play it. Includes musical instrument toy version.
    • Vial: A whole barrel of the legendary norn beer, Bear's Brown Ale. Your character occasionally makes drunk jokes. Frost effect, plus tiny pink elephants appear around you.
    • Polearm: Dual-bladed djinn elemental scythe, effects changing from fire to ice. Aura and footsteps change their effects as well, synchronized with the weapon.
    • Relic: Cauldron of Cataclysm, a handheld replica of the artifact behind the Searing of Ascalon.

    Time for another update:

    New weapons

    These are my 4 ideal weapons, for a total of 20.

    • Satchel: One-handed, can be wielded in one hand or both. Thrown, inspired by the Grenade Satchel of the engineer.
    • Spear: One-handed, can be wielded in one hand or both. Melee and thrown.
    • Battlegloves: Two-handed. They replace active glove skins when wielded. Melee and ranged.
    • Polearm: Two-handed. Includes greataxes, scythes, halberds, longspears, and more. Melee.

    Each core profession would unlock one or two of the above for free, without any specialization requirements. Further unlocks would become possible through elite specializations. These core unlocks would be as follows:

    • Elementalist: Battlegloves.
    • Mesmer: Satchel.
    • Necromancer: Polearm.
    • Engineer: Satchel, Battlegloves.
    • Ranger: Spear.
    • Thief: Satchel, Battlegloves.
    • Guardian: Spear.
    • Revenant: Polearm.
    • Warrior: Spear, Polearm.

    I feel like these four are more solid than the six I had before. Few design notes:

    • Off-hand weapons weren't engaging enough, and feel a bit like filler, so I just removed them. Both the Vial and the Bell could return as weapon kits, slot skills, bundles, or just animations.
    • Satchel gives us more thrown options, and allows grenade-like gameplay to expand outside engineer. I consider it an evolution of the Vial. It would replace the Grenade Kit on the engineer.
    • Fists were renamed to Battlegloves, and reclassified as two-handed. Figured out the weapon skills would feel better if they used both hands for everything. They would be usable for both melee combat and casting magical ranged attacks.
    • Relic is gone, since it felt a bit clunky. Still has potential as a weapon kit profession mechanic, with dedicated skins.
    • Spear and Polearm were already solid enough, so they stay the same.

    Bonus: Elite specialization ideas

    Few elite specialization ideas, using both new and repurposed weapon types:

    • Elementalist - Dervish: Polearm (scythe skin).
    • Mesmer - Dreamcharmer: Dagger (fan skin).
    • Necromancer - Apothecary: Satchel (plague bomb skin).
    • Ranger - Beastlord: Polearm (greataxe skin).
    • Thief - Bladewind: Axe (boomerang skin).
    • Guardian - Paragon: Polearm (two-handed spear skin).
    • Revenant - Hierophant: Battlegloves (Flame Legion Shaman skin).
    • Warrior - Gladiator: Staff (trident skin).

    Been a while since the last time, here's another take, combining the best of all previous ideas:

    New weapons

    These are my latest 4 ideal weapons, for a total of 20.

    • Battleglove: One-handed, can be wielded in one hand or both. They replace active glove skins when wielded. Melee and ranged.
    • Spear: One-handed, can be wielded in one hand or both. Melee and thrown.
    • Polearm: Two-handed. Includes greataxes, scythes, halberds, longspears, and more. Melee.
    • Relic: Two-handed. Magical artifact inspired by GW1's ritualist item spells. Floats on the left hand, while you cast with the right hand. Includes astrolabes, cauldrons, musical instruments, ashes, tablets, and more. Ranged.

    Each core profession would unlock one or two of the above for free, without any specialization requirements. Further unlocks would become possible through elite specializations. These core unlocks would be as follows:

    • Elementalist: Battlegloves, Relic.
    • Mesmer: Relic.
    • Necromancer: Polearm.
    • Engineer: Battlegloves.
    • Ranger: Spear.
    • Thief: Battlegloves.
    • Guardian: Spear.
    • Revenant: Polearm, Relic.
    • Warrior: Spear, Polearm.

    Few design notes:

    • Satchels don't convince me as "wielded weapons" anymore, and I feel like they would work far better as kits or thrown skills, as long as they're handled properly, like new elite specialization mechanics, an elixir rework, or just a new slot skill type altogether.
    • Battlegloves are back to one-handed. There might be situations where a single battleglove could combine well with other one-handed weapons, and the two-handed restriction wasn't mandatory anyway.
    • Relic is back, since I still feel like we need more magical weapons. However, this time it draws inspiration from GW1's ritualist item spells. It's no longer inspired by guardian tomes, which would remain exclusive to the firebrand's elite specialization mechanic's theme.
    • Spear and Polearm still remain solid enough, so they stay the same once again.

    Well, I think this is a pretty good final version, but who knows, new ideas might change everything in a few months once again =).

  • Kodama.6453Kodama.6453 Member ✭✭✭✭

    @Conncept.7638 said:
    I cannot believe you don't have tomes on the first priority list.

    • Like the underwater weapons, they are, or were, already in game.
    • As a magic weapon, it would be more particle effect driven, requiring way less animation work than any martial weapon.
    • There are no caster weapons left. The game only launched with three, already available to every caster profession. There is so much design space left for more traditional spellcasting, but no magic weapons to place traditional spellcasting skills on.
    • And finally, we already have a profession that should have had it, the axe makes absolutely no sense for the firebrand and was clearly a tacked on compromise on the firebrands aesthetic and theme. We have a sophisticated mystical librarian and lorekeeper, wielding the most primitive, brutish, barbaric weapon in the game.

    I think the axe actually makes sense for firebrand and this also showcases the issue I see with new weapon types.
    There is simply no need for new weapon types in this game, since every profession still has weapon slots open and if these weapons make sense on them or not is up to interpretation.

    Like someone already mentioned, we have a dueling mage using a greatsword.... At first, this might sound strange. But they use this weapon to channel their magic and summon magical sword illusions to throw at their enemies.

    Or the firebrand: You say it makes no sense that we have a sophisticated librarian wielding the "most primitive, brutish, barbaric weapon in the game".
    Now I think you can interpret what you said there in a different way... where you see something "primitive", I say "traditional". In real world, axes were some of the most ancient weapons used by humanity. For me, the firebrand is also about tradition, especially as a lorekeeper. And it makes sense that they are wielding the weapons of their ancestors, axes, even if these might seem less refined than other weapons.

    Anet has proven to be creative with their weapon designs and especially the magic wielding classes should not have any problems to use the weapons available in unexpected ways. All needed is that they come up with a coherent theme, which I think they succeeded with so far.

    So I personally prefer if we stick to the already established weapons, especially since introducing new weapon types could create a huge problem with balance.

  • Dawdler.8521Dawdler.8521 Member ✭✭✭✭

    Calling them battlegloves is stupid. Its just so over the top. Like calling a dagger a "warspike" or calling a staff a "siegepole".

    I dont approve unless they are called punchmittens.

    gaggle - /ˈɡaɡ(ə)l/ - noun
    A disorderly group of Asura.
    "The gaggle of Asura tried to agree on whether a phase-shifted thermonuclear energy matrix was sufficiently powerful for a device capable of heating bread"

  • Kodama.6453Kodama.6453 Member ✭✭✭✭

    @Dawdler.8521 said:
    Calling them battlegloves is stupid. Its just so over the top. Like calling a dagger a "warspike" or calling a staff a "siegepole".

    I dont approve unless they are called punchmittens.

    The intention here is most likely to make a clear differentiation between the armor gloves and weapon gloves. If you just call them gloves or gauntlets, then there is the potential that these 2 get confused for armor pieces instead.

    Also we need hydraulic power gloves for the engineer, something big for smashing, like the gauntlets Vi has from League of Legends or the brawlers from TERA.

  • Lonami.2987Lonami.2987 Member ✭✭✭✭
    edited September 11, 2020

    @Lonami.2987 said:

    @Lonami.2987 said:

    @Lonami.2987 said:
    The original idea feels somewhat outdated, and I have changed a few opinions since I posted it, in part thanks to everyone contributing. So I guess it's time for an update!

    Here's my new take, I'm a bit less rigid with the animation department this time, and I'm going harder for the cool factor too. I still think this set is fairly viable, and includes more variety, with more potential for originality. Hope you like it!

    New weapons

    These are my 6 ideal weapons, for a total of 22.

    • Fists: One-handed, can be wielded in one hand or both. They replace active glove skins when wielded.
    • Spear: One-handed, can be wielded in one hand or both. Mostly ranged usage.
    • Bell: Off-hand. Percussion instrument, played to vibrate ambient magic. Connected to geomancy.
    • Vial: Off-hand. Container of liquid which can be drunk, spilled, or thrown. Includes bottles of wine, magic potions, steins of beer, barrels, and more.
    • Polearm: Two-handed. Includes greataxes, scythes, halberds, longspears, and more.
    • Relic: Two-handed. Magical artifact inspired by the old guardian tomes. Floats on the left hand, while you cast with the right hand. Includes books of magic, astrolabes, cauldrons, musical instruments, ashes, tablets, and more.

    Each core profession would unlock two of the above for free, without any specialization requirements. Further unlocks would become possible through elite specializations. These core unlocks would be as follows:

    • Elementalist: Bell, Relic.
    • Mesmer: Vial, Relic.
    • Necromancer: Bell, Polearm.
    • Engineer: Fists, Vial.
    • Ranger: Spear, Bell.
    • Thief: Fists, Spear.
    • Guardian: Spear, Relic.
    • Revenant: Fists, Polearm.
    • Warrior: Vial, Polearm.

    Underwater weapons

    You might have noticed I didn't count the 3 underwater weapons when counting above. That's because I'm merging them with some of the ground weapons. They would remain separate equipment-wise, but use the same skin pool.

    • Harpoon (old spear) merges with polearm.
    • Speargun (old harpoon gun) merges with rifle.
    • Trident merges with staff.

    You would still need to craft them separately, so for example, you wouldn't be able to use a trident as a staff. This merge only covers skins, effectively removing underwater weapons from the wardrobe.

    Updates to old weapons

    Other potential new weapons would be included inside the existing types. Few examples:

    • Axes now include chakrams, boomerangs, and other thrown blades.
    • Daggers now include fans.
    • Maces now include one-handed hammers.
    • Rifles now include crossbows.
    • Shortbows now include slingshots.

    I feel like this model is much more solid than my previous idea, and also includes more exciting new options.

    Bonus: New legendary weapons

    Because, why not?

    • Fists: Steam-powered mecha-hands, the wrists rotate in combat like a drill.
    • Spear: GW1's Voltaic Spears, this time with more lightning.
    • Bell: Instead of a handheld bell, a floating familiar carries a Canthan jade tower bell by your side, and you pull the rope to play it. Includes musical instrument toy version.
    • Vial: A whole barrel of the legendary norn beer, Bear's Brown Ale. Your character occasionally makes drunk jokes. Frost effect, plus tiny pink elephants appear around you.
    • Polearm: Dual-bladed djinn elemental scythe, effects changing from fire to ice. Aura and footsteps change their effects as well, synchronized with the weapon.
    • Relic: Cauldron of Cataclysm, a handheld replica of the artifact behind the Searing of Ascalon.

    Time for another update:

    New weapons

    These are my 4 ideal weapons, for a total of 20.

    • Satchel: One-handed, can be wielded in one hand or both. Thrown, inspired by the Grenade Satchel of the engineer.
    • Spear: One-handed, can be wielded in one hand or both. Melee and thrown.
    • Battlegloves: Two-handed. They replace active glove skins when wielded. Melee and ranged.
    • Polearm: Two-handed. Includes greataxes, scythes, halberds, longspears, and more. Melee.

    Each core profession would unlock one or two of the above for free, without any specialization requirements. Further unlocks would become possible through elite specializations. These core unlocks would be as follows:

    • Elementalist: Battlegloves.
    • Mesmer: Satchel.
    • Necromancer: Polearm.
    • Engineer: Satchel, Battlegloves.
    • Ranger: Spear.
    • Thief: Satchel, Battlegloves.
    • Guardian: Spear.
    • Revenant: Polearm.
    • Warrior: Spear, Polearm.

    I feel like these four are more solid than the six I had before. Few design notes:

    • Off-hand weapons weren't engaging enough, and feel a bit like filler, so I just removed them. Both the Vial and the Bell could return as weapon kits, slot skills, bundles, or just animations.
    • Satchel gives us more thrown options, and allows grenade-like gameplay to expand outside engineer. I consider it an evolution of the Vial. It would replace the Grenade Kit on the engineer.
    • Fists were renamed to Battlegloves, and reclassified as two-handed. Figured out the weapon skills would feel better if they used both hands for everything. They would be usable for both melee combat and casting magical ranged attacks.
    • Relic is gone, since it felt a bit clunky. Still has potential as a weapon kit profession mechanic, with dedicated skins.
    • Spear and Polearm were already solid enough, so they stay the same.

    Bonus: Elite specialization ideas

    Few elite specialization ideas, using both new and repurposed weapon types:

    • Elementalist - Dervish: Polearm (scythe skin).
    • Mesmer - Dreamcharmer: Dagger (fan skin).
    • Necromancer - Apothecary: Satchel (plague bomb skin).
    • Ranger - Beastlord: Polearm (greataxe skin).
    • Thief - Bladewind: Axe (boomerang skin).
    • Guardian - Paragon: Polearm (two-handed spear skin).
    • Revenant - Hierophant: Battlegloves (Flame Legion Shaman skin).
    • Warrior - Gladiator: Staff (trident skin).

    Been a while since the last time, here's another take, combining the best of all previous ideas:

    New weapons

    These are my latest 4 ideal weapons, for a total of 20.

    • Battleglove: One-handed, can be wielded in one hand or both. They replace active glove skins when wielded. Melee and ranged.
    • Spear: One-handed, can be wielded in one hand or both. Melee and thrown.
    • Polearm: Two-handed. Includes greataxes, scythes, halberds, longspears, and more. Melee.
    • Relic: Two-handed. Magical artifact inspired by GW1's ritualist item spells. Floats on the left hand, while you cast with the right hand. Includes astrolabes, cauldrons, musical instruments, ashes, tablets, and more. Ranged.

    Each core profession would unlock one or two of the above for free, without any specialization requirements. Further unlocks would become possible through elite specializations. These core unlocks would be as follows:

    • Elementalist: Battlegloves, Relic.
    • Mesmer: Relic.
    • Necromancer: Polearm.
    • Engineer: Battlegloves.
    • Ranger: Spear.
    • Thief: Battlegloves.
    • Guardian: Spear.
    • Revenant: Polearm, Relic.
    • Warrior: Spear, Polearm.

    Few design notes:

    • Satchels don't convince me as "wielded weapons" anymore, and I feel like they would work far better as kits or thrown skills, as long as they're handled properly, like new elite specialization mechanics, an elixir rework, or just a new slot skill type altogether.
    • Battlegloves are back to one-handed. There might be situations where a single battleglove could combine well with other one-handed weapons, and the two-handed restriction wasn't mandatory anyway.
    • Relic is back, since I still feel like we need more magical weapons. However, this time it draws inspiration from GW1's ritualist item spells. It's no longer inspired by guardian tomes, which would remain exclusive to the firebrand's elite specialization mechanic's theme.
    • Spear and Polearm still remain solid enough, so they stay the same once again.

    Well, I think this is a pretty good final version, but who knows, new ideas might change everything in a few months once again =).

    Let's go for another round:

    New weapon types

    These are my 4 ideal weapons, for a total of 20.

    Few design notes:

    • Battlegloves have been renamed to Knuckles, and no longer replace glove skins by default.
    • Spear has been restricted to main-hand only. I know there's multiple enemies ingame who wield spears in both hands, but you never get to actually see them use the second hand.
    • No changes for Polearm and Relic.

    Core professions update

    Each core profession would unlock one or two of the above for free, without any specialization requirements. Further unlocks would become possible through elite specializations. These core unlocks would be as follows:

    • Elementalist: Relic.
    • Mesmer: Relic.
    • Necromancer: Polearm.
    • Engineer: Knuckles.
    • Ranger: Spear.
    • Thief: Knuckles.
    • Guardian: Spear, Relic.
    • Revenant: Knuckles, Polearm.
    • Warrior: Spear, Polearm.

    Updates to wardrobe restrictions

    Some of the new weapons already "exist" as skins for other weapon types. The easiest solution would be to duplicate them across the different types, but what if we took it further, and removed some of the type-based wardrobe restrictions?

    For example, we could enable usage of trident or polearm skins on a staff, removing the need for duplicates and increasing overall skin value.

    The lifted restrictions would be as follows:

    • Focus ⬅ Scepter, Knuckles.
    • Longbow ⬅ Shortbow.
    • Rifle ⬅ Speargun.
    • Shortbow ⬅ Longbow.
    • Scepter ⬅ Mace.
    • Spear ⬅ Harpoon, Trident.
    • Staff ⬅ Polearm, Spear, Harpoon, Trident.

    Underwater weapons would be affected as well:

    • Harpoon ⬅ Polearm, Spear, Trident.
    • Speargun ⬅ Rifle.
    • Trident ⬅ Polearm, Spear, Staff, Harpoon.

    This idea can be applied to armor skins too:

    • Back item ⬅ Shield (stowed).
    • Aquatic Headgear ⬅ Headgear.

    Once these restrictions have been lifted, the existing conflictive skins can be reclassified easily with no need for duplicates. For example, existing scythe-like staff skins would be transformed into polearm skins, and be usable by both polearms and staves. Some foci skins such as the Chak Focus or the Mist Lord's Focus would be transformed into knuckles skins, and be usable by both knuckles and foci.

    @Kodama.6453 said:
    So I personally prefer if we stick to the already established weapons, especially since introducing new weapon types could create a huge problem with balance.

    What balance problems? Weapon types have no gameplay impact, they're just skin families. There's no difference between giving the warrior a staff or a polearm, since the real work lies at the new weapon skills.

    @Kodama.6453 said:
    Also we need hydraulic power gloves for the engineer, something big for smashing, like the gauntlets Vi has from League of Legends or the brawlers from TERA.

    A fellow man of culture, I see =).

  • Arcaedus.7290Arcaedus.7290 Member ✭✭✭✭
    edited September 5, 2020

    Hey Lonami, just read through your post, and I think you have wonderful ideas. I wanted to address this point here:

    @Lonami.2987 said:

    • Spear: Could be adapted for main-hand and off-hand usage.
    • Harpoon gun: Doesn’t make a lot of sense at land, but some of the simplest existing skins, as well as future skins, could be adapted to depict crossbows instead.
    • Trident: With the spear being one-handed, the trident would remain relevant as a two-handed longspear of sorts.

    So I've mentioned this idea before, but I think an absolutely great way to add weapon variety into the game with this new expac would be to:

    1. Add in 1-3 entirely new weapon types. Almost every new elite spec would be getting one of these
    2. Additionally, make underwater weapons amphibious and let one or both of them be available for core classes.

    So with this, the expac would bring 2-3 new weapons for everyone.

    Second point there could be accomplished through narrative quite easily imo. There could be something in the expac about "repurposing" underwater weapons as land weapons due to their effectiveness at taking down underwater creatures (that are on land/floating in the air.... because Elder Dragon magic).

    Spear --> repurposed into a one-handed melee weapon, very similar to Paragon from GW1
    Trident --> repurposed into the two-handed polearm (2h spear). Similar to GS, maybe slightly lower dps, but more versatile (has some range on its attacks, variety of moveset, like blocks, parries, leaps, evades, a thrown attack, rapid-hitting attacks, wide-range melee aoe)
    Harpoon gun --> repurposed into either an explosive weapon, or a crossbow/crossbowgun.

    For the land version of harpoon gun, so many different things could be done with this - it could be a 2h mid-range weapon that focuses on large AOEs and is a bit on the slower side, it could be a 1h ranged weapon that focuses more on CC and AOE than pistol, or it could be an off-hand only weapon that has a lot of utility, kind of like the Clutch Claw in Monster Hunter World. Sky's the limit, yo.

  • JohnWater.5760JohnWater.5760 Member ✭✭✭
    edited September 8, 2020

    @Klowdy.3126 said:
    Tomes are now abilities, used by two classes. They aren't going to turn them into something that is bought/dropped after implementing them as spells, especially since one is an elite spec.

    Firebrand and?

    I love the Idea of adding tomes to more classes.
    I think is pretty hard to they implement new weapons, there's a lot of things to do if so.
    More balance(The current one is already a mess)
    More skins(The hardest part, there are a lot of skins to make)
    Which classes are going to get it?
    Too much job for something not so required, I think.
    If they are going to put new weapons, it will probably be added as mechanics or skills (Conjures, kits, tomes ...)

  • @JohnWater.5760 said:

    @Klowdy.3126 said:
    Tomes are now abilities, used by two classes. They aren't going to turn them into something that is bought/dropped after implementing them as spells, especially since one is an elite spec.

    Firebrand and?

    I love the Idea of adding tomes to more classes.
    I think is pretty hard to they implement new weapons, there's a lot of things to do if so.
    More balance(The current one is already a mess)
    More skins(The hardest part, there are a lot of skins to make)
    Which classes are going to get it?
    Too much job for something not so required, I think.
    If they are going to put new weapons, it will probably be added as mechanics or skills (Conjures, kits, tomes ...)

    Tomes are like Attunements

  • Lonami.2987Lonami.2987 Member ✭✭✭✭

    @Arcaedus.7290 said:
    Hey Lonami, just read through your post, and I think you have wonderful ideas. I wanted to address this point here:

    @Lonami.2987 said:

    • Spear: Could be adapted for main-hand and off-hand usage.
    • Harpoon gun: Doesn’t make a lot of sense at land, but some of the simplest existing skins, as well as future skins, could be adapted to depict crossbows instead.
    • Trident: With the spear being one-handed, the trident would remain relevant as a two-handed longspear of sorts.

    So I've mentioned this idea before, but I think an absolutely great way to add weapon variety into the game with this new expac would be to:

    1. Add in 1-3 entirely new weapon types. Almost every new elite spec would be getting one of these
    2. Additionally, make underwater weapons amphibious and let one or both of them be available for core classes.

    So with this, the expac would bring 2-3 new weapons for everyone.

    Second point there could be accomplished through narrative quite easily imo. There could be something in the expac about "repurposing" underwater weapons as land weapons due to their effectiveness at taking down underwater creatures (that are on land/floating in the air.... because Elder Dragon magic).

    Spear --> repurposed into a one-handed melee weapon, very similar to Paragon from GW1
    Trident --> repurposed into the two-handed polearm (2h spear). Similar to GS, maybe slightly lower dps, but more versatile (has some range on its attacks, variety of moveset, like blocks, parries, leaps, evades, a thrown attack, rapid-hitting attacks, wide-range melee aoe)
    Harpoon gun --> repurposed into either an explosive weapon, or a crossbow/crossbowgun.

    For the land version of harpoon gun, so many different things could be done with this - it could be a 2h mid-range weapon that focuses on large AOEs and is a bit on the slower side, it could be a 1h ranged weapon that focuses more on CC and AOE than pistol, or it could be an off-hand only weapon that has a lot of utility, kind of like the Clutch Claw in Monster Hunter World. Sky's the limit, yo.

    You replied to the oldest version, I've posted multiple updates across the thread, last one here: https://en-forum.guildwars2.com/discussion/comment/1320850/#Comment_1320850 :P.

    I wouldn't bring underwater weapons into land anymore, only their skins. Underwater weapons are pretty bad anyway.

    @JohnWater.5760 said:

    @Klowdy.3126 said:
    Tomes are now abilities, used by two classes. They aren't going to turn them into something that is bought/dropped after implementing them as spells, especially since one is an elite spec.

    Firebrand and?

    I love the Idea of adding tomes to more classes.
    I think is pretty hard to they implement new weapons, there's a lot of things to do if so.
    More balance(The current one is already a mess)
    More skins(The hardest part, there are a lot of skins to make)
    Which classes are going to get it?
    Too much job for something not so required, I think.
    If they are going to put new weapons, it will probably be added as mechanics or skills (Conjures, kits, tomes ...)

    They don't need to make skins for all the missing sets... they haven't done that for underwater weapons since many years ago.

    @VocalThought.9835 said:

    @JohnWater.5760 said:

    @Klowdy.3126 said:
    Tomes are now abilities, used by two classes. They aren't going to turn them into something that is bought/dropped after implementing them as spells, especially since one is an elite spec.

    Firebrand and?

    I love the Idea of adding tomes to more classes.
    I think is pretty hard to they implement new weapons, there's a lot of things to do if so.
    More balance(The current one is already a mess)
    More skins(The hardest part, there are a lot of skins to make)
    Which classes are going to get it?
    Too much job for something not so required, I think.
    If they are going to put new weapons, it will probably be added as mechanics or skills (Conjures, kits, tomes ...)

    Tomes are like Attunements

    More like engineer kits, really.

  • @Lonami.2987 said:

    @Arcaedus.7290 said:
    Hey Lonami, just read through your post, and I think you have wonderful ideas. I wanted to address this point here:

    @Lonami.2987 said:

    • Spear: Could be adapted for main-hand and off-hand usage.
    • Harpoon gun: Doesn’t make a lot of sense at land, but some of the simplest existing skins, as well as future skins, could be adapted to depict crossbows instead.
    • Trident: With the spear being one-handed, the trident would remain relevant as a two-handed longspear of sorts.

    So I've mentioned this idea before, but I think an absolutely great way to add weapon variety into the game with this new expac would be to:

    1. Add in 1-3 entirely new weapon types. Almost every new elite spec would be getting one of these
    2. Additionally, make underwater weapons amphibious and let one or both of them be available for core classes.

    So with this, the expac would bring 2-3 new weapons for everyone.

    Second point there could be accomplished through narrative quite easily imo. There could be something in the expac about "repurposing" underwater weapons as land weapons due to their effectiveness at taking down underwater creatures (that are on land/floating in the air.... because Elder Dragon magic).

    Spear --> repurposed into a one-handed melee weapon, very similar to Paragon from GW1
    Trident --> repurposed into the two-handed polearm (2h spear). Similar to GS, maybe slightly lower dps, but more versatile (has some range on its attacks, variety of moveset, like blocks, parries, leaps, evades, a thrown attack, rapid-hitting attacks, wide-range melee aoe)
    Harpoon gun --> repurposed into either an explosive weapon, or a crossbow/crossbowgun.

    For the land version of harpoon gun, so many different things could be done with this - it could be a 2h mid-range weapon that focuses on large AOEs and is a bit on the slower side, it could be a 1h ranged weapon that focuses more on CC and AOE than pistol, or it could be an off-hand only weapon that has a lot of utility, kind of like the Clutch Claw in Monster Hunter World. Sky's the limit, yo.

    You replied to the oldest version, I've posted multiple updates across the thread, last one here: https://en-forum.guildwars2.com/discussion/comment/1320850/#Comment_1320850 :P.

    I wouldn't bring underwater weapons into land anymore, only their skins. Underwater weapons are pretty bad anyway.

    @JohnWater.5760 said:

    @Klowdy.3126 said:
    Tomes are now abilities, used by two classes. They aren't going to turn them into something that is bought/dropped after implementing them as spells, especially since one is an elite spec.

    Firebrand and?

    I love the Idea of adding tomes to more classes.
    I think is pretty hard to they implement new weapons, there's a lot of things to do if so.
    More balance(The current one is already a mess)
    More skins(The hardest part, there are a lot of skins to make)
    Which classes are going to get it?
    Too much job for something not so required, I think.
    If they are going to put new weapons, it will probably be added as mechanics or skills (Conjures, kits, tomes ...)

    They don't need to make skins for all the missing sets... they haven't done that for underwater weapons since many years ago.

    @VocalThought.9835 said:

    @JohnWater.5760 said:

    @Klowdy.3126 said:
    Tomes are now abilities, used by two classes. They aren't going to turn them into something that is bought/dropped after implementing them as spells, especially since one is an elite spec.

    Firebrand and?

    I love the Idea of adding tomes to more classes.
    I think is pretty hard to they implement new weapons, there's a lot of things to do if so.
    More balance(The current one is already a mess)
    More skins(The hardest part, there are a lot of skins to make)
    Which classes are going to get it?
    Too much job for something not so required, I think.
    If they are going to put new weapons, it will probably be added as mechanics or skills (Conjures, kits, tomes ...)

    Tomes are like Attunements

    More like engineer kits, really.

    No, cause kit are a utility and Attunement are F abilities

  • Lonami.2987Lonami.2987 Member ✭✭✭✭

    @Lonami.2987 said:

    @Lonami.2987 said:

    @Lonami.2987 said:

    @Lonami.2987 said:
    The original idea feels somewhat outdated, and I have changed a few opinions since I posted it, in part thanks to everyone contributing. So I guess it's time for an update!

    Here's my new take, I'm a bit less rigid with the animation department this time, and I'm going harder for the cool factor too. I still think this set is fairly viable, and includes more variety, with more potential for originality. Hope you like it!

    New weapons

    These are my 6 ideal weapons, for a total of 22.

    • Fists: One-handed, can be wielded in one hand or both. They replace active glove skins when wielded.
    • Spear: One-handed, can be wielded in one hand or both. Mostly ranged usage.
    • Bell: Off-hand. Percussion instrument, played to vibrate ambient magic. Connected to geomancy.
    • Vial: Off-hand. Container of liquid which can be drunk, spilled, or thrown. Includes bottles of wine, magic potions, steins of beer, barrels, and more.
    • Polearm: Two-handed. Includes greataxes, scythes, halberds, longspears, and more.
    • Relic: Two-handed. Magical artifact inspired by the old guardian tomes. Floats on the left hand, while you cast with the right hand. Includes books of magic, astrolabes, cauldrons, musical instruments, ashes, tablets, and more.

    Each core profession would unlock two of the above for free, without any specialization requirements. Further unlocks would become possible through elite specializations. These core unlocks would be as follows:

    • Elementalist: Bell, Relic.
    • Mesmer: Vial, Relic.
    • Necromancer: Bell, Polearm.
    • Engineer: Fists, Vial.
    • Ranger: Spear, Bell.
    • Thief: Fists, Spear.
    • Guardian: Spear, Relic.
    • Revenant: Fists, Polearm.
    • Warrior: Vial, Polearm.

    Underwater weapons

    You might have noticed I didn't count the 3 underwater weapons when counting above. That's because I'm merging them with some of the ground weapons. They would remain separate equipment-wise, but use the same skin pool.

    • Harpoon (old spear) merges with polearm.
    • Speargun (old harpoon gun) merges with rifle.
    • Trident merges with staff.

    You would still need to craft them separately, so for example, you wouldn't be able to use a trident as a staff. This merge only covers skins, effectively removing underwater weapons from the wardrobe.

    Updates to old weapons

    Other potential new weapons would be included inside the existing types. Few examples:

    • Axes now include chakrams, boomerangs, and other thrown blades.
    • Daggers now include fans.
    • Maces now include one-handed hammers.
    • Rifles now include crossbows.
    • Shortbows now include slingshots.

    I feel like this model is much more solid than my previous idea, and also includes more exciting new options.

    Bonus: New legendary weapons

    Because, why not?

    • Fists: Steam-powered mecha-hands, the wrists rotate in combat like a drill.
    • Spear: GW1's Voltaic Spears, this time with more lightning.
    • Bell: Instead of a handheld bell, a floating familiar carries a Canthan jade tower bell by your side, and you pull the rope to play it. Includes musical instrument toy version.
    • Vial: A whole barrel of the legendary norn beer, Bear's Brown Ale. Your character occasionally makes drunk jokes. Frost effect, plus tiny pink elephants appear around you.
    • Polearm: Dual-bladed djinn elemental scythe, effects changing from fire to ice. Aura and footsteps change their effects as well, synchronized with the weapon.
    • Relic: Cauldron of Cataclysm, a handheld replica of the artifact behind the Searing of Ascalon.

    Time for another update:

    New weapons

    These are my 4 ideal weapons, for a total of 20.

    • Satchel: One-handed, can be wielded in one hand or both. Thrown, inspired by the Grenade Satchel of the engineer.
    • Spear: One-handed, can be wielded in one hand or both. Melee and thrown.
    • Battlegloves: Two-handed. They replace active glove skins when wielded. Melee and ranged.
    • Polearm: Two-handed. Includes greataxes, scythes, halberds, longspears, and more. Melee.

    Each core profession would unlock one or two of the above for free, without any specialization requirements. Further unlocks would become possible through elite specializations. These core unlocks would be as follows:

    • Elementalist: Battlegloves.
    • Mesmer: Satchel.
    • Necromancer: Polearm.
    • Engineer: Satchel, Battlegloves.
    • Ranger: Spear.
    • Thief: Satchel, Battlegloves.
    • Guardian: Spear.
    • Revenant: Polearm.
    • Warrior: Spear, Polearm.

    I feel like these four are more solid than the six I had before. Few design notes:

    • Off-hand weapons weren't engaging enough, and feel a bit like filler, so I just removed them. Both the Vial and the Bell could return as weapon kits, slot skills, bundles, or just animations.
    • Satchel gives us more thrown options, and allows grenade-like gameplay to expand outside engineer. I consider it an evolution of the Vial. It would replace the Grenade Kit on the engineer.
    • Fists were renamed to Battlegloves, and reclassified as two-handed. Figured out the weapon skills would feel better if they used both hands for everything. They would be usable for both melee combat and casting magical ranged attacks.
    • Relic is gone, since it felt a bit clunky. Still has potential as a weapon kit profession mechanic, with dedicated skins.
    • Spear and Polearm were already solid enough, so they stay the same.

    Bonus: Elite specialization ideas

    Few elite specialization ideas, using both new and repurposed weapon types:

    • Elementalist - Dervish: Polearm (scythe skin).
    • Mesmer - Dreamcharmer: Dagger (fan skin).
    • Necromancer - Apothecary: Satchel (plague bomb skin).
    • Ranger - Beastlord: Polearm (greataxe skin).
    • Thief - Bladewind: Axe (boomerang skin).
    • Guardian - Paragon: Polearm (two-handed spear skin).
    • Revenant - Hierophant: Battlegloves (Flame Legion Shaman skin).
    • Warrior - Gladiator: Staff (trident skin).

    Been a while since the last time, here's another take, combining the best of all previous ideas:

    New weapons

    These are my latest 4 ideal weapons, for a total of 20.

    • Battleglove: One-handed, can be wielded in one hand or both. They replace active glove skins when wielded. Melee and ranged.
    • Spear: One-handed, can be wielded in one hand or both. Melee and thrown.
    • Polearm: Two-handed. Includes greataxes, scythes, halberds, longspears, and more. Melee.
    • Relic: Two-handed. Magical artifact inspired by GW1's ritualist item spells. Floats on the left hand, while you cast with the right hand. Includes astrolabes, cauldrons, musical instruments, ashes, tablets, and more. Ranged.

    Each core profession would unlock one or two of the above for free, without any specialization requirements. Further unlocks would become possible through elite specializations. These core unlocks would be as follows:

    • Elementalist: Battlegloves, Relic.
    • Mesmer: Relic.
    • Necromancer: Polearm.
    • Engineer: Battlegloves.
    • Ranger: Spear.
    • Thief: Battlegloves.
    • Guardian: Spear.
    • Revenant: Polearm, Relic.
    • Warrior: Spear, Polearm.

    Few design notes:

    • Satchels don't convince me as "wielded weapons" anymore, and I feel like they would work far better as kits or thrown skills, as long as they're handled properly, like new elite specialization mechanics, an elixir rework, or just a new slot skill type altogether.
    • Battlegloves are back to one-handed. There might be situations where a single battleglove could combine well with other one-handed weapons, and the two-handed restriction wasn't mandatory anyway.
    • Relic is back, since I still feel like we need more magical weapons. However, this time it draws inspiration from GW1's ritualist item spells. It's no longer inspired by guardian tomes, which would remain exclusive to the firebrand's elite specialization mechanic's theme.
    • Spear and Polearm still remain solid enough, so they stay the same once again.

    Well, I think this is a pretty good final version, but who knows, new ideas might change everything in a few months once again =).

    Let's go for another round:

    New weapon types

    These are my 4 ideal weapons, for a total of 20.

    Few design notes:

    • Battlegloves have been renamed to Knuckles, and no longer replace glove skins by default.
    • Spear has been restricted to main-hand only. I know there's multiple enemies ingame who wield spears in both hands, but you never get to actually see them use the second hand.
    • No changes for Polearm and Relic.

    Core professions update

    Each core profession would unlock one or two of the above for free, without any specialization requirements. Further unlocks would become possible through elite specializations. These core unlocks would be as follows:

    • Elementalist: Relic.
    • Mesmer: Relic.
    • Necromancer: Polearm.
    • Engineer: Knuckles.
    • Ranger: Spear.
    • Thief: Knuckles.
    • Guardian: Spear, Relic.
    • Revenant: Knuckles, Polearm.
    • Warrior: Spear, Polearm.

    Updates to wardrobe restrictions

    Some of the new weapons already "exist" as skins for other weapon types. The easiest solution would be to duplicate them across the different types, but what if we took it further, and removed some of the type-based wardrobe restrictions?

    For example, we could enable usage of trident or polearm skins on a staff, removing the need for duplicates and increasing overall skin value.

    The lifted restrictions would be as follows:

    • Focus ⬅ Scepter, Knuckles.
    • Longbow ⬅ Shortbow.
    • Rifle ⬅ Speargun.
    • Shortbow ⬅ Longbow.
    • Scepter ⬅ Mace.
    • Spear ⬅ Harpoon, Trident.
    • Staff ⬅ Polearm, Spear, Harpoon, Trident.

    Underwater weapons would be affected as well:

    • Harpoon ⬅ Polearm, Spear, Trident.
    • Speargun ⬅ Rifle.
    • Trident ⬅ Polearm, Spear, Staff, Harpoon.

    This idea can be applied to armor skins too:

    • Back item ⬅ Shield (stowed).
    • Aquatic Headgear ⬅ Headgear.

    Once these restrictions have been lifted, the existing conflictive skins can be reclassified easily with no need for duplicates. For example, existing scythe-like staff skins would be transformed into polearm skins, and be usable by both polearms and staves. Some foci skins such as the Chak Focus or the Mist Lord's Focus would be transformed into knuckles skins, and be usable by both knuckles and foci.

    Another round:

    New weapon types

    These are my ideal weapons, for a total of 18.

    Few design notes:

    • Longbow and Shortbow have been merged into a single weapon type, called just Bow. The Ranger uses both weapons, so his shortbow skills will be transformed into dagger skills, and his original dagger skills will be transformed into Knuckles skills.
    • Still not convinced by Relic too much, so it's gone once again.
    • No changes for Spear, Knuckles, and Polearm.

    Core professions update

    Each core profession would unlock some of the old and new weapon types for free, without any specialization requirements. These core unlocks would be as follows:

    • Elementalist: Greatsword, Polearm.
    • Mesmer: Pistol (main-hand), Warhorn.
    • Necromancer: Axe (off-hand), Polearm.
    • Engineer: Knuckles (main-hand and off-hand), Mace (main-hand and off-hand).
    • Ranger: Spear.
    • Thief: Spear, Knuckles (main-hand and off-hand).
    • Guardian: Spear.
    • Revenant: Axe (main-hand), Mace (off-hand), Knuckles (main-hand and off-hand).
    • Warrior: Polearm.

    Further unlocks would become possible through new elite specializations and additional core profession updates.

  • First I must commend you on really sticking with your ideas and coming back to them, it’s been cool to see them develop. And also warriors should definitely get knuckles as a core profession update

  • Opopanax.1803Opopanax.1803 Member ✭✭✭✭
    edited December 13, 2020

    A lot of thought has gone in to this. Although very unlikely Anet would do something like this due to animation and artist costs, here are my 2cents.

    I would prefer that each profession get another 1 base weapon and do updates on core weapons, skills, and traits that need it... instead of another specialization for the expansion. This would breath more life into the game for me, so I would take this trade off of Anets resources.

    Also, I could see INSTEAD of giving different classes different types of all new weapons, I could see ANET giving EVERY PROFESSION A SPEAR AS A CORE LAND WEAPON and then customize it to be ranged, melee, defense/utility, support, or dps focused based on what the class needed. I think that this would actually work out well for resource use as well as an even playing field without anyone being left out.
    This would leave engineer's shield a bit out in the cold still, as they have no MH Power weapon to pair with shield, but it would at least give them another option.

  • Mace for engy seems the most logical, as it can be used mh and oh. Engy needs another off hander. I say this because pistol is used for both mh and Oh. A focus or a torch would be most class appropriate. I don’t think knuckles is a good suggestion, since engy already is the most lacking class in amount of weapon types. It’s also far from being class appropriate.

    2h - rifle and hammer
    Mh - pistol and sword
    Oh - pistol and shield

  • @Opopanax.1803 said:

    This would leave engineer's shield a bit out in the cold still, as they have no MH Power weapon to pair with shield, but it would at least give them another option.

    Mh sword is the power mh weapon for engineer.

  • Opopanax.1803Opopanax.1803 Member ✭✭✭✭

    @scorekeeper.6524 said:

    @Opopanax.1803 said:

    This would leave engineer's shield a bit out in the cold still, as they have no MH Power weapon to pair with shield, but it would at least give them another option.

    Mh sword is the power mh weapon for engineer.

    You don't have sword as core 1-80, and not as scrapper, and not any future elites.

  • Axl.8924Axl.8924 Member ✭✭✭✭

    @Gulesave.5073 said:

    @OriOri.8724 said:
    I really don't see the need for new weapon types in this game. I mean, even warrior, the class who can currently wield the most weapons in the game, still has 6 open weapon slots, allowing for 6 more elite specs before he runs out just with the current weapons (or 5 if he gets dual pistols in a single spec like he got dual daggers). Even at that point though, assuming GW3 isn't out yet, there's nothing preventing a new warrior elite from re-using a weapon a previous one used. Nothing stopping the new one from re-using torch for instance.

    Plus, on the other hand, we already have plenty of open "slots" for weapons. Scepter could be adapted as a second hand weapon for an elite spec, torch/focus/warhorn could be adapted as mainhand weapons for some elite specs (and shield too as a stretch for an extremely defensive oriented spec). There's just no need for new weapon types, and no matter how they would be implemented it would have huge drawbacks ("wasted" dev time by creating skins for them for every existing set and recipes for making them, despite it not being new content. Or having an extremely limited set of skins for these new weapons, which you can bet real money on would definitely kitten off a lot of players who play fashion wars).

    I love writing up ideas for using offhand weapons in the main hand, or vice versa. Guardian with MH shield to toss in mid-range. Thief with MH torch for smokey goodness. Dual scepter warrior who uses them as beating sticks? Go for it!

    Limitation fuels creativity. If you really want other weapon types, they can always be kits or conjures. Reaper gets a scythe in shroud form already. Somebody could just as easily call up a spear, crossbow, or whatever else.

    @Conncept.7638 said:

    @Klowdy.3126 said:

    @Conncept.7638 said:
    I cannot believe you don't have tomes on the first priority list.

    • Like the underwater weapons, they are, or were, already in game.
    • As a magic weapon, it would be more particle effect driven, requiring way less animation work than any martial weapon.
    • There are no caster weapons left. The game only launched with three, already available to every caster profession. There is so much design space left for more traditional spellcasting, but no magic weapons to place traditional spellcasting skills on.
    • And finally, we already have a profession that should have had it, the axe makes absolutely no sense for the firebrand and was clearly a tacked on compromise on the firebrands aesthetic and theme. We have a sophisticated mystical librarian and lorekeeper, wielding the most primitive, brutish, barbaric weapon in the game.

    Tomes are now abilities, used by two classes. They aren't going to turn them into something that is bought/dropped after implementing them as spells, especially since one is an elite spec.

    "I'm using a tome in order to use my tomes more effectively...in my tome build...with tomes"

    No.

    Well then the OP is moot, if we're going to accept nonsensical weapons then there isn't any point in exploring new weapon types.

    Or... and here me out here, you could stop making vain attempts to shut down peoples suggestions in ways completely illogical to a suggestion thread to make yourself feel important and empowered.

    We're already suggesting major changes to the game here, as that was the purpose of the thread. And you're making assumptions about those suggestions says nothing about the suggestions themselves, but about you and your conduct. What I was suggesting was that "tomes" not be the firebrand class mechanic in favor of it being added as a real weapon, as anyone could have figured out upon reading my suggestion. But you didn't want to come to that conclusion, it didn't give you the opportunity to put yourself up by shutting others down.

    And that change would more easily be made than adding any weapon to the game, because, as the entire guardian forum has pointed out for two months on end, tomes are tomes practically in name only these days, they are included in a brief casting animation and then never seen, you would literally have to change a single animation and sub out a single word in the FBs skillset. Oh how terrible, we changed a word, the firebrand is ruined.

    I dunno orb fits elementalist perfectly and skull for necromancer skull of some powerful dead guy or something no? i mean eles bieng casters would love some form of magic orb to channel elements no?

    Here is my list of characters i got so far:

    Elementalist 80 with tempest:Talman nul
    Necromancer 80 with reaper:Zex vokar
    Mesmer level 80 no chrono yet:Klanga voosh.
    Level 80 Ranger with druid spec Jedkhan.

  • Yes i'd love for the Underwater weapons to be added asap as Ground variants. They can just convert the underwater skills for land use.
    2h Spear
    2h Trident
    2h harpoon Gun / Crossbow

    Secondly.
    2h Greataxe
    1h Knuckles
    2h Grimoire

  • Fueki.4753Fueki.4753 Member ✭✭✭✭
    edited December 15, 2020

    @Axl.8924 said:
    I dunno orb fits elementalist perfectly and skull for necromancer skull of some powerful dead guy or something no? i mean eles bieng casters would love some form of magic orb to channel elements no?

    These actually sound like they'd fit as Focus skins, rather than being their own weapon categories.

  • The Boz.2038The Boz.2038 Member ✭✭✭

    Skulls already exist. Remember Adam? It's just that they're held awkwardly.
    And I really want land use water weapons. Harpoons for Engineers? Easy to envision. Spears for Warrior, Ranger? Piece of cake. Trident? Say hello to the Necromancer, baby.

  • Lonami.2987Lonami.2987 Member ✭✭✭✭
    edited February 7, 2021

    @Yung Reezy.8479 said:
    First I must commend you on really sticking with your ideas and coming back to them, it’s been cool to see them develop. And also warriors should definitely get knuckles as a core profession update

    Thanks! Check my Ideas for 9 new Canthan elite specializations as well if you like my work :smile:.

    @Fueki.4753 said:

    @Axl.8924 said:
    I dunno orb fits elementalist perfectly and skull for necromancer skull of some powerful dead guy or something no? i mean eles bieng casters would love some form of magic orb to channel elements no?

    These actually sound like they'd fit as Focus skins, rather than being their own weapon categories.

    Foci have always been kind of a mess, it's kinda sad they never got properly established as "real" magical artifacts (such as orbs, books, etc) and instead we got a series of weird gizmos that don't look either useful or cool in any way whatsoever. I mean, just look at the gallery.

  • Fueki.4753Fueki.4753 Member ✭✭✭✭

    @Lonami.2987 said:
    Foci have always been kind of a mess, it's kinda sad they never got properly established as "real" magical artifacts (such as orbs, books, etc) and instead we got a series of weird gizmos that don't look either useful or cool in any way whatsoever.

    Considering the range of things their equivalents in GW1 and WoW are, I don't mind that.

  • Axl.8924Axl.8924 Member ✭✭✭✭

    @Lonami.2987 said:

    @Yung Reezy.8479 said:
    First I must commend you on really sticking with your ideas and coming back to them, it’s been cool to see them develop. And also warriors should definitely get knuckles as a core profession update

    Thanks! Check my Ideas for 9 new Canthan elite specializations as well if you like my work :smile:.

    @Fueki.4753 said:

    @Axl.8924 said:
    I dunno orb fits elementalist perfectly and skull for necromancer skull of some powerful dead guy or something no? i mean eles bieng casters would love some form of magic orb to channel elements no?

    These actually sound like they'd fit as Focus skins, rather than being their own weapon categories.

    Foci have always been kind of a mess, it's kinda sad they never got properly established as "real" magical artifacts (such as orbs, books, etc) and instead we got a series of weird gizmos that don't look either useful or cool in any way whatsoever. I mean, just look at the gallery.

    Its because they need to perhaps buff it to make it useful. At times they nerf things into oblivion.

    Maybe its better we don't get more weapons, because look at wow being a mess from having a bunch of classes and elite specs and trying to balance it for pvp pve and raids.

    I've seen some on forum complain and say threaten they leaving, and this game has huge amounts of issues balancing too, so perhaps its better to have a limited amount and really balance them properly to be good in certain situations.

    Here is my list of characters i got so far:

    Elementalist 80 with tempest:Talman nul
    Necromancer 80 with reaper:Zex vokar
    Mesmer level 80 no chrono yet:Klanga voosh.
    Level 80 Ranger with druid spec Jedkhan.