How would you redesign the revenant?
Lonami.2987
Member ✭✭✭✭
Do you feel like the revenant could be much more? That his mechanics don't do his theme justice? Maybe his elite specializations have a weak design? Or do you just want to post some crazy ideas? Well, then this thread is for you.
So, just for fun, how would you redesign the revenant?
Last update here: May 5, 2018
Few personal ideas to start the thread:
Revenant - Full redesign (first option)
Revenant is a mess, but that shouldn't be news for anyone. I don't know what happened during development, but it's clear that something didn't click. I will be going for a hard redesign, trying to get something unique out of what we have now.
The first problem is energy. They wanted to do something that required resource management, and I guess it works for the slot skills, but it's too much for the weapon skills. Either remove the cooldowns, or remove energy. The second problem is the legend-locked slot skill bar. While nice at the beginning, because you have double the skills, it turns boring quickly, because of the lack of customization.
Personally, I'd remove both of them. They have no useful purpose whatsoever, and they just don't work. The thief is the only profession with outside-mechanic resource management, and it works well, because his weapon skills are very reactive and situational. That's totally not the case with revenant.
So, energy is gone. Weapon skills now work just with cooldowns. The next step is to give revenants the same slot skill model every other profession has, where they choose the slot skills they want from a list. Most of the legend-locked slot skills would be easily adapted into a neutral version, and the rest would need to be made from scratch. The usual stuff would be fine, some signets, tricks, stances, etc. Look for inspiration in GW1's ritualist, monk, and dervish. It would be nice if core revenant is a viable healer as well, so we don't depend on druids that much.
With that clear, let's move onto the mechanic, which is what really defines the profession.
We want something unique, and we want the legends to be there somehow, too. Transformations, attunements, kits, etc, are already taken by other professions.
The revenant has something unique, though: Ventari's Tablet. Annoying at the first glance, most of its problems came from it being in slot skills instead of the mechanic bar. So, what if we adapt the tablet, and turn it into a mechanic? It would be similar to the ranger's pet, but an object instead of an animal, with some differences.
Before continuing, let me say that I don't feel like Mallyx is a good character to represent the Demon/Margonite legend, and that I would replace him with Varesh Ossa, who has far more story and personality. Also, I feel like the revenant needs a fifth legend, because four aren't enough for customization. My candidate would be Bonfaaz Burntfur as "Legendary Imperator". He's the charr shaman who summoned the Searing of Ascalon. Flame Legion magic is really cool and has no place among the other professions, so he's a perfect candidate, and his inclusion would also complete the triune of Abaddon servants, representing the titans. Also, I'd rename Shiro from "Assassin" to "Envoy", to avoid confusion with a potential future thief assassin elite specialization.
So, back to the tablet adaptation, each legend would have its own Relic, a non-autonomous artifact that you would control manually, with some special abilities. The removed legend skills would be integrated into the new F1-F2-F3 relic skills, some of which would include movement options. F4 would swap the relic. The gameplay would focus on positioning the relic correctly during the fights. The relics would also give a passive bonus to nearby allies, kinda like warrior banners.
Generally speaking, F1 would have a movement skill, F2 a support skill, and F3 the ultimate skill, which would destroy the relic upon usage, forcing a relic swap. Some relic examples:
Centaur: Ventari's Tablet
- Ventari's Will: Move the tablet, healing allies it passes through.
- Protective Solace: Summon a protective barrier to destroy enemy projectiles and heal allies.
- Dream of Dreams: Heal allies around the relic, and leave fragments for allies to heal further.
Dwarf: Tome of the Rubicon
- Inspiring Reinforcement: Move the tome, leaving a stone road in its path.
- Connect the lifes of nearby allies, distributing received damage between them.
- Rite of the Great Dwarf: Reduce incoming damage to nearby allies.
Envoy: Jade Wind Orb
- Move the orb, and siphon life from enemies it passes through.
- Pull nearby enemies, and steal their boons.
- Jade Winds: Stun/freeze nearby enemies for a short duration.
Imperator: Cauldron of Cataclysm
- Move the cauldron, leaving a fiery trail.
- Fire field, give might and fury to nearby allies.
- Searing of Ascalon: Large AoE damage around the relic.
Margonite: Apocrypha
- Move the tablet, crippling enemies in its path.
- Area of effect that convert boons of nearby enemies into conditions.
- Nightfall: Blind, chill, and torment nearby enemies.
This gives the revenant an unique mechanic, unlike none seen by other core profession. Relics would replace legends, and you'd only be able to equip two at the same time.
Finally, give some new weapons to core revenant to solve the weapon skill variety problems, and we'd be ready to go. Main-hand axe, off-hand mace, torch, and focus should do it.
The relic system shouldn't be the norm for all elite specializations. Some could replace it with something else, or remove it altogether.
Revenant - Full redesign (second option)
An alternative to the above idea, born from the same principles. Instead of relics, it would use Spirit Weapons, a new type of minion, that wouldn't attack or move unless commanded. Similar in concept to guardian spirit weapons.
This redesign would also include a fifth legend, but with the new mechanic it makes no sense to keep the previous choice. I'll go with Master Togo instead, as "Legendary Ritualist", since the new mechanic is heavily inspired by GW1's weapon spells and item spells, and revenant could really use some binding rituals as slot skills anyway.
These spirit weapons would float behind the revenant, waiting to strike. Each legendary character would have his own set, formed by six weapons. Every set would have five hidden basic skills, each linked to a weapon skill slot, and they would play whenever you use its linked weapon skill slot. Also, there would be three mechanic skills at slots F1, F2, and F3, for special abilities. Some examples:
- Centaur: Harathi Scepters. Healing role.
- Dwarf: Deldrimor Maces. Defensive role.
- Envoy: Shiro'ken Swords. Direct Damage role.
- Margonite: Tormented Sickles. Condition Damage role.
- Ritualist: Imperial Urns. Support role.
So, if your current legend is dwarf, using the second weapon skill (no matter which weapon you're wielding, be it sword, staff, etc) would trigger the second skill from the Deldrimor Maces. This could require an update for weapon skills, to make sure every slot has a common role so you don't get weird combinations.
Both this idea and the previous one could be used as elite specialization ideas instead, too.
Herald - Full redesign
The herald is really dull from a theme perspective. It feels like they built this elite specialization together with the core profession, and that decision affected both negatively. Elite specializations should be about new mechanics and new playstyles, not fixing holes from their core professions.
What's a herald, anyway? Sounds like someone who embodies something. A transformation mechanic could fit him really well, so why not?
The herald's new mechanic would be a transformation, turning you into a living avatar of your current legend, much like the necromancer's Death Shroud. It would use the F5 mechanic button, and there would be a total of six avatar options, five from the core legends, and one from the elite legend, Glint. The transformation would change your physical aspect, boost your attributes, and replace your weapon skills, until you decide to go back to normal. No time limit, like engineer kits and soulbeast beastmode. You can swap transformation while transformed, too.
Transforming would destroy your current relic, so you have to choose between the F3 ultimate skill or the F5 transformation. The relics and their skills would be unavailable while transformed. Each transformation would have an unique model, with no sexual or racial distinctions. Examples:
- Centaur: You become Ventari, a male centaur, wielding a staff. Healer role.
- Dwarf: You become Jalis Ironhammer, a stone dwarf, wielding the Hammer of the Great Dwarf. Tank role.
- Envoy: You become Shiro Tagachi, a male human, wielding Shiro's Blades. Melee DPS role.
- Margonite: You become Varesh Ossa, a female margonite, wielding a scythe. Melee condition damage role.
- Dragon: You become a smaller version of Glint, a female crystal dragon, wielding no weapons. You can breathe fire, knock down enemies with your tail, and launch enemies by flapping your wings. You can user your gliding skills while in this form. Ranged DPS role.
- Imperator: You become Bonfaaz Burntfur, a male Flame Legion charr. Ranged condition damage role. (First revenant redesign idea)
- Ritualist: You become Togo, a male human, wielding a scepter and a focus. Support role. (Second revenant redesign idea)
While transformed, your voice commands would be replaced by those of your active legend, and the legend's whispers would be replaced by whispers from your own character, arguing with the legend about what to do next.
Going by the first redesign idea, Glint would have her own relic too, a scroll with the Flameseeker Prophecies, with various support options. Going by the second idea, her spirit weapons would be crystalline spears.
As for the original mechanic of the herald, facets, they would be turned into slot skills, with the same mantra-like functionality, sans the energy limitation.
Renegade - Full redesign
When I first heard about the renegade, I was somewhat excited. It sounded like you were going to fight beside your own warband. Imagine my disappointment when said warband members were nothing more than just some random immobile banners.
This redesign idea is simple: Make the warband fight besides you.
We would use a new system for this: The swarm. Similar to the ranger's pet system, but with multiple pets at once.
This wouldn't work well with the relic system from the previous redesign, so we would ditch it for this elite specialization. I'm a firm believer that elite specializations should bring new mechanics, and sometimes replace the old mechanics as well, and this would be one of those cases.
Each legend would have its own warband, with three heroes, each with unique skills. Each member would represent a character from the past, not necessarily contemporary or aligned with his parent legend, so you could say they are echoes rather than actual ghosts. The entire system itself would pay homage to the hero system of GW1.
Centaur: Followers of Ventari
Dwarf: The Royal Guard
Envoy: Doom of the Betrayer
Margonite: Generals of Kourna
Renegade: Razor Warband
Imperator: The Shaman Caste (If we implement the first revenant redesign idea above)
Ritualist: The Tengu Delegates (If we implement the second revenant redesign idea above)
All the swarms would work the same way. Mechanic skills F1, F2, and F3 would be tied to one hero each, F4 would be a group action for the three heroes, and F5 would swap legend, switching to another swarm. Each hero would have an individual health bar, and if dead, his skill would change to a respawn option.
The new slot skills would be shouts, themed around boosting the heroes and giving them orders.
Just some random ideas to begin the thread. Waiting for yours! 
Profession Redesign series:
Elementalist - Mesmer - Necromancer - Engineer - Ranger - Thief - Guardian - Revenant - Warrior
PROFESSION REDESIGN SERIES ⇒ Elementalist - Mesmer - Necromancer - Engineer - Ranger - Thief - Guardian - Revenant - Warrior
CANTHAN ELITE SPECIALIZATIONS ⇒ Skyfire - Trickster - Apothecary - Dreadnought - Bulwark - Shadowblade - Spiritcaller - Windwalker - Thunderlord
Comments
while i think there needs to be a bunch of changes to the revenant. I am satisfied with the concept, but I do think a number of issues need to be addressed in some manner.
However, not to be mean but the whole idea to make everything a ground targeted tablet really makes me cringe. The rev couldn't even enter the water, because we wouldn't have a single legend that would be useable.
A rework like this would require the resources akin to those needed for an entire set of elite specs, or even an entire expansion, combined.
I'm not huge fan of the whole thing, to be honest. I like Rev as is. It needs some work, but it doesn't need to be broken down and rebuild as something else entirely.
The main problem, from my perspective and experience playing the class, is the limited choice in utility skills. Some skills simply have limited or next to no usefulness in certain modes. I've seen people suggest to allow us to mix and match utility skills regardless of equipped legend, but I feel that just makes the legend swapping system redundant, or at least strips it of its unique identity.
Two other ideas I've seen being suggested (repeatedly), which I do believe have some potential, is to either create a set of general revenant utility skills that can be used with any legend, or add an extra, fourth utility skill for every legend currently in the game and with future elite specs.
The Revenant isn't so far gone that it needs to be remade from the ground up. I for one think it all "clicks" but that there's an issue of how everything runs on its own. If we're throwing out big change ideas I'll contribute my ideas. This here regards baseline Revenant without either Elite spec:
With Herald, the same ideas of no-utility cooldown are still in play but work a little differently. Because of how Facets work on the Glint Legend, you can't manually deactivate them without swapping Legends, depleting your energy, or consuming the Facet and forcing it onto cooldown. Simply put, I would maintain how they are now but remove the cooldown after activating the Consume Facet and instead make each Consume Facet require an energy cost. If you're above that energy cost, you will consume the Facet, use the skill, and it deactivates but if you're below the energy cost you simply deactivate the Facet. This will create a need for Energy above neutral energy generation while on Glint because of the weapon skills no longer costing energy. The global healing skill timer would only affect Consume Facet of Light allowing Glint's Legend to use the Regen Facet freely and if activated while the cooldown is still in place, it will simply deactivate the Facet much like if you had not enough Energy for the other Facets.
I have many ideas for Renegade but none that I could solidly put into words for this post. The most immediate change would be to disconnect the GM traits from "Improved Kalla's Fervor". I said this before the Lasting Legacy nerf and I will say it again, tying so much damage into that Trait is unhealthy for the trait line. Renegade is built as a damage spec and that additional damage from that trait suffocates the viability of the other two GM traits. While Righteous Rebel got a big buff, it's still caught in the limbo around Lasting Legacy. Make what "Improved Kalla's Fervor" is baseline to Renegade (so that each stack of Kalla's Fervor always grants 3% condi damage and 50 ferocity) and instead make Lasting Legacy more about offense boon support. Adding group Fury to Lasting Legacy would be great as it would provide a source of Fury to Renegade besides the lackluster "gain Fury when you hit a 50% health enemy". Renegade has two traits in Renegade's trait line that activate when gaining Fury yet only has that one source of Fury that only begins to activate after something you're fighting is half defeated. This would allow Renegade to look at their GM traits more actively depending on their party composition like many other specs do: they can take the Might and Fury from Lasting Legacy if the group needs it, they can take the Alacrity from Righteous Rebel if the group needs it, or they can take the additional damage from Vindication if the group doesn't need the Renegade to provide any more support. This change would be extremely healthy for Renegade.
Remove legend swap and energy. Select utilities like every other class.
What would you implement as a unique mechanic in its place?
Please no, profession mechanic that makes you move around a tablet the whole time would make me drop this class for good. ventari tablet is the worst part of rev, I'd rework that legend completely, not make the whole profession revolve around it.
I think rev is good in concept, like a lot of people I think a full rework would be removing energy costs on weapons, and adding an extra utility skill to each legend so you have some choice. I don't think weapon skills need increased cd's, they're already in line with other proffesion cd's. Having extra utility skills to choose from would help the pvp/pve balance; like assassin stance are all pretty usefull in pvp, where mobility is huge and quickness is rare. But none of the skills increase your dps, which is all that matters in pve, so shiro stance is basically useless there. If you add an extra utility that increases dps so you could replace impossible odds with it for pve content, you could buff power rev back into viability.
Dwarf stance and ventari could use full reworks on abilities; dwarf abilites are all random and have no synergy, and the tablet is really unfun to lug around.
Unlike quite a few in this thread I think many of the underlying concepts are quite valid for a class. I'd keep most of them. That being said, I'd make massive reworks to how traits/scaling works to enable actual non-hybrid-but-role-switchin play, something clearly indicated by the current setup of invoking these legends, but never implemented well.
Passive bonuses of invoked legend
First of all, each legend needs to enable you to fulfill its primary role even if you lack the gear for it. To that end, they should all give massive buffs to you whenever they are enabled. These are very distinctly not obtained through some trait, but part of the base legend. Examples:
And so on. The idea being that even if I am a power DPS Revenant, should I switch to Ventari I'm an "okay" healer. Likewise if I go Mallyx I'm an "alright" condition damage dealer. To balance this, overall base scaling of Revenant has to be lower than other specs, though IMO I'd do this via traits: Revenant would not have minor traits, flat out. As so much power is passively baked into the legends, there's no need to bake passive power into the traitlines.
Energy income and expense
To go with the above change, I'd use energy more as a "role commitment" mechanic, to curb the flexibility the inherently strong legends offer. So it'd work like this:
How i'd do it
:
Legend now just grant you a bonus/an aura of power when you have it.
Shiro: increase power damage by 10% (grant 180 power from F2)
Mallyx: Reduce condition damage taken -20% (15% from F2)
Jalis: Reduce incoming damage -20% (15% from F2)
Ventari: Outgoing healing +10% (+10% incoming heal with F2)
Glint: Boon duration +20% (10% from F2)
Kalla: Movement speed +33% (25% from F2)
Add a F2 that summon the spirit of your current legend spreading a lessen effect to nearby allies for a 5 upkeep cost. CD 30 seconds. (revenant also affected)
A function skill tied to the selected legend. Like what herald and kalla offer.
Yeah, I think these two are the biggest problems with revenant. I understand that some people love them, but I'm confident they're hurting the profession design. It's the same with the elementalist and the engineer, they have more options than the rest, and that leads to those options being worse for balance's sake.
And that's where I personally would like the discussion to go. A new unique mechanic, to replace energy and legend-locked slot skills. Not some dumb skills which are no different than weapon or slot skills, or a copy of a mechanic already used by another profession. Something really unique that stands out on its own.
I went the tablet 2.0 route, because the positioning gameplay could be really fun, but there could be other options, like removing the tablet altogether, and saving it for an elite specialization. Few ideas:
I don't know, anyone else has any other ideas? The last one, floating weapons, is the only one from those above that I think could work, but should go in line with a mesmer redesign so that both are kept unique. I could elaborate on it later, just need to rewrite my notes on it.
Edit: I've added the floating weapon idea to the first post:
Revenant - Full redesign (second option)
An alternative to the above idea, born from the same principles. Instead of relics, it would use Spirit Weapons, a new type of minion, that wouldn't attack or move unless commanded. Similar in concept to guardian spirit weapons
This redesign would also include a fifth legend, but with the new mechanic it makes no sense to keep the previous choice. I'll go with Master Togo instead, as "Legendary Ritualist", since the new mechanic is heavily inspired by GW1's weapon spells and item spells, and revenant could really use some binding rituals as slot skills anyway.
These spirit weapons would float behind the revenant, waiting to strike. Each legendary character would have his own set, formed by six weapons. Every set would have five hidden basic skills, each linked to a weapon skill slot, and they would play whenever you use its linked weapon skill slot. Also, there would be three mechanic skills at slots F1, F2, and F3, for special abilities. Some examples:
So, if your current legend is dwarf, using the second weapon skill (no matter which weapon you're wielding, be it sword, staff, etc) would trigger the second skill from the Deldrimor Maces. This could require an update for weapon skills, to make sure every slot has a common role so you don't get weird combinations.
Both this idea and the previous one could be used as elite specialization ideas instead, too.
This could work well too, and it's pretty unique on its own.
My major gripe with Ventari's Tablet is that it's in the slot skills, not the tablet itself. I think positioning elements and then making them do stuff is an interesting idea, that no other profession explores. Only the Scourge has something similar with the shades.
The relic (Tablet 2.0) idea is for the mechanic skills only. Slot skills would be freely selectable from a list, like all the other professions.
PROFESSION REDESIGN SERIES ⇒ Elementalist - Mesmer - Necromancer - Engineer - Ranger - Thief - Guardian - Revenant - Warrior
CANTHAN ELITE SPECIALIZATIONS ⇒ Skyfire - Trickster - Apothecary - Dreadnought - Bulwark - Shadowblade - Spiritcaller - Windwalker - Thunderlord
I know many players here want to change how your utilities are confined to a single Legend but I think removing the Legend-locked utilities and making it a free-for-all would be a mistake. The swapping right bar is Revenant's most unique aspect and rather than making it a free-for-all, I support adding additional utility skills on each individual Legend.
Add an additional resource on top of Energy, transforming Revenant into dual-resource class that balances both. Like Windwalker with Energy+Chi in Legion.
Yeah, I stream once in a blue moon.
It doesn't need a redesign. If only balance changes were made that didn't go against the current design, everything about Revenant would actually be fine. It's all the counter-intuitive changes that were made over the past two years that need to be addressed.
Why have this energy mechanic, then start attaching cooldowns that defeat the purpose?
Why keep reducing/removing our damage skills and traits, but leave us weak to conditions?
Why only improve support skills/traits? Are we supposed to be heavily armored cheerleaders?
I would be down to play a heavily armored cheerleader if we could compete with Druid and Chrono.
This. Even our support specs are nothing compared to them.
I don’t think a full redesign is necessary. I like the idea of switching focus mid-fight. No other class can swap 6-10 skills mid fight. It just sucks that those 6-10 skills compete with our weapon skills for energy. Compared to a thief...2-5 are based on initiative...6-10 are on timers. Dropping energy costs on 2-5 would be a good QoL improvement.
I like the idea of adding a 4th utility per stance. It would give some better build options. And with 2 elite specs rev has 21 posibile utility skills...other classes get 28 utility options. But Inthink legend-locking those utilities should stay...that’s part of the class.
Also...Renegade is suppose to be an ambush class, yet it has 0 stealth or otherwise skills to reflect that. Whereas a mirage just has to dodge to open up an ambush skill. Its like the person who was working on the renegade came up with that idea then got moved to the mirage team.
The 7 changes (not complete overhauls) I think would make the most difference (plus would make most of them work underwater) are as follows:
1. add 2 more utility skills to each legend
2. every base legend needs an F2 ability that is specific to the legend you are using, and Herald/Kalla would add extra F abilities
2. Glint/Herald - needs to be switched to use the ammo system. Anet already switched a bunch of other skills to and leave the F2 the upkeep. Also get rid of the big dragon animation on the elite skill - it sucks to have such a huge telegraphed elite.
3. kalla/renegade - needs to be changed to work how the current Glint/Heralds functions, with the mobile AOE with upkeeps
4. make the Invocation line all about invoking the legends. so base it on when your swap you legend and whether your health is high/low, energy high/low, condition/boons, # of enemies/allies around you. This means every trait not just 3 of the 12 like it currently is.
5. (someone else suggested this, but it was a cool concept) Make the Venturi/Salvation have 2 different modes - stowed and not stowed. So this means your utility skills 6-0 would work similar to how they work now, but stowed would be more selfish, whereas summoned would be more group focused. Your F2 skill would summon and stow the tablet.
6. remove the little healing orbs that venturi and the staff drop and just make it an AOE.
This one is an overall comment towards all professions.
Make each trait actually mean something - get rid of the minor trait line and just give us 3 or 4 choices in each line(currently some are meaningless/useless - so there could probably just be 3 like it currently is). Plus, make it a choice and a difficult choice at that. You can have this or that - NOT both or all. traits should be about flavor, not if you have a permanent speed boost or do 7% more damage. If a profession needs to have these types of traits, then Anet was either being lazy or profession need a boost somewhere and should be looked at.
To be honest, any redesign of rev would be better than it's current form right now.
just no. As much as I like ventari I don't want that mechanic on every single legend.
As of now, I would do only 2 main changes:
☆ SUGGEST-A-TRON
I would just do a partial redesign, targeting Herald and Retribution traitlines as well as Sword.
1)I would remove the Eye for an Eye trait and move Steadfast Rejuvenation in it's place
2)I would place Enhanced Bulwark in the place where Steadfast Rejuvenation was originaly
3)I would change Soothing Bastion to trigger on being disabled with a recharge of 60
4)I would add a trait where Enhanced Bulwark was originaly that reduces weapon recharge rate by 20% while in Dragon Stance and by 10% while outside of it.This trait will be called Elder's Finesse
5)I would swap the places of Sword 3 with Sword 5, so off hand sword can be our best hybrid weapon (viable for both condi and power builds, grants us the ability to gain evade frames and a small chance to land an aoe attack that imobilizez opponents). Sword main hand will also transform from a balanced weapon,to a very aggresive weapon on top of which you can add the offense leaning axe off hand
6)I would change Steadfast Rejuvenation to reduce the casting time of Jallis heal to 3/4 and have it gain a 25% for it to activate when your health drops to 50% while outside of Legendary Dwarf Stance. The recharge for the passive effect will be 45. - this is done so Jallis can be as viable as Kala is for PvP, in terms of having a legend stance where you build up energy just so you can blast your weapon skills like fireworks during new years and have a reliable heal on the side.
1) Rework it so 1-5 abilities don't require energy. The worst part about rev now is that if you the gameplay is way to based on "either/or" ... if I use impossible odds for the dps boost, I can only auto-attack (which is boring and makes it feel like I am playing WoW or EQ again). If I want to use 1-5 abilities for more "active" combat, I won't have the energy for my utilities when I need them.
2) Give revs a choice of utilities, (and maybe even for heals and elites) based on the legend chosen. This goes back to the last sentence in my first paragraph a little. Right now, so many utilities in the revenant kit are so situational, but the way rev plays is that you either sit on energy (and do nothing and be bored and don't do much damage) so that you can use the right utility when the situation comes up, or you attempt to get the most damage out of your rev and then when you need a defensive move or escape or whatever, you're out of energy. I think the intent was to make gameplay more difficult and interactive, but it has the opposite effect. Every other prof has plenty of "oh shnikeys" buttons, but only the rev has to kitten his play just to ensure he can use it.
3) If you don't do 1 or 2 then they should at least have some abilities GAIN energy for more interesting ways to play rev.
The problem is... we got limited build options because locked utility sets, and on top of that, we have mana (renamed energy) AND cooldowns. If you've played the other profs and know the fluidity of having no resource like energy/mana, revenant will always feel off.
Yep we need at least 2 more utilities per legend and a set of generic utilities for invocation. Maybe a something that would max out our energy or give us something like barrier to you energy bar - so instead of maxing at 100%, maybe we can get 150%. Then Anet could give us an extra main and/or offhand weapon to go with it.
However, I posted this somewhere else - reduce energy cost and recharge time by 50% for 2 weeks or a month and see what happens. If it seems OP at that point then re-adjust.
As long as he gets something new in exchange, it should be fine. Legend-swapping is like attunements and kits anyway, it's not that special.
I do think the legend-locked slot skills are his biggest problem from a balance perspective, hence why I like to search a replacement for them.
Agree with the second point, Facet of Nature and Citadel Orders should only be available when using Glint and Kalla respectively. The other legends need their own things in that place, either unique stuff, or skills based on a shared theme from the elite specialization.
What about the second idea, the one with the "spirit weapons"?
I just want Ventari's Tablet outside the slot skills, I don't care if it has to be removed and reintroduced later with a new elite specialization using relics.
The problem with that is it becomes a logistical nightmare in the long term, since revenant keeps getting more and more legends and weapons, growing the work exponentially. The elementalist has four attunements, and no more, so the different weapon skills work.
I think the major culprit of this is the concept of legends itself, which can't be properly represented without multiple restrictions. Had they used "schools of magic" or whatever instead, we would be better now. Something like "crystal magic" and then you can attune the crystals to 4-5 types, and you choose 2 at a time, and all your attacks use crystalline effects (instead of the ugly black/red mist thing) which can be dyed with your current type. Then new elite specializations don't add new crystal types at all, so it stays viable and non-exponential. My only gripe with this idea is that it's too similar to the elementalist, and I prefer having unique mechanics for each core profession.
PROFESSION REDESIGN SERIES ⇒ Elementalist - Mesmer - Necromancer - Engineer - Ranger - Thief - Guardian - Revenant - Warrior
CANTHAN ELITE SPECIALIZATIONS ⇒ Skyfire - Trickster - Apothecary - Dreadnought - Bulwark - Shadowblade - Spiritcaller - Windwalker - Thunderlord
I would start by giving them herald and renegade from day one. Step two would be giving two eelite specs that change how the class plays (like every other class), and not just complete the half finished mess.
The way the legends function is fine - each one basically has a different play style, but need to be more defined. The real issue is lack of skills or meaningful traits. each legend should have a condi clear, and the healing shouldn't be weak as kitten. I hate getting hit with huge damage and the only way to really heal is heal with one legend and then swap to the other legend quickly, just get a decent heal. unless that heal is shiro, where the heal is worthless and mitigatable with all the blocks/invulns/blinks/stealths/dodges available to some classes. When you hit the button is should just heal you and steal health from your target (unblockable/non-mitigatable), but if you have no target it just heals whatever the full amount is.
This is just a Christmas wish, but having a trait in renegade - like the one that gives protection to allies, but instead removes stealth at a 360 distance around the avatars and another one that knocks down foes in the area. These would make up 3 flavorful traits.
The new elites specs should either add something really different or super charge the functionality of one of the existing play style. I don't think we are to a point where super charging a play style should happen yet.
I would give them about 15 new skills not associated with a legend that could be swapped around in their utility bar. Then, I'd change it so that instead of swapping between two legends, you swap into and out of one legend (the legends would retain their current fixed 5 skills).
Each legend would have a specialized role, while non-legend mode would be designed to be customizable, versatile, and able to synergize well with any of the legends. Legends would use energy while non-legend skills would not. Energy would refill in a similar way to how it does now. Much like with Ele, it would be viable to stay in a legend full time, or to never invoke a legend, but it would be a bit more optimal to go in and out of legend based on ability and energy needs.
I don't think rev needs to be completley reworked, it's close to being good and unique, just needs a few changes. For one, give each legend an additional utility to choose from. This way you could make every stance relevant for pve and pvp. Like assassin stance is great in pvp, but every single skill is useless in pve where someone else is already giving you quickness and you really dont need use energy to dodge or gap close. Give it another utility that increases its dps that people can take in pve. In pvp it would be a choice of taking more damage vs more mobility.
Also it's really just weird how weapon skills have both an energy cost and a cd. Rework it so that one of these things is removed; preferably the energy cost.
Get rid of the cooldowns, with the exception of self-heals.
Send renegade back to the drawing board.
honestly, its too late for a complete rework but that is what is required to make revenant as smooth as other classes. For right now we can only hope for changes to make more builds effective and competitive. But yeah, just the weapons on their own don't mesh together. They are all trying to do something different with out actually doing a lot of what they need to do. I would say the mace/axe combo is the only weapon set that is complete and smooth. The swords are clunky and have too many useless situational skills. Sword 2 is good in 1v1, but splitting the projectiles and not giving them splash damage makes this skill sorta a waste. Sword 3 is a cool looking skill that doesn't do much, its best used to just postpone death a couple of seconds. The offhand sword skills in there new iteration help a bit and give sword a more assassin like feel, but rev still has trouble sticking around in battle or outright ganking someone quick enough. The staff is cool because of the cc, but its traits are attached to the healing spec which isn't useful unless you're going straight up healing. Staff is just a utility/defence weapon and I suppose it is an alright weapon, but doesn't mesh with the revenant unless your healing or bunkering. The hammer is a cool gimmick, but it has no use in actual combat where you are being attacked. The shield is nice I guess, but the immobile heal is ridiculous and is more of a death postpone. The shortbow just does abysmal damage and sorta functions like a longbow without the added range. I almost do more damage with mace/axe at range, and the mace/axe has more utility and survivability.
My suggestions are vague but I would say regroup and think of what you want the rev to be. A heavy armored assassin like originally, a beefy bruiser with consistent damage, or something else like having a focus on lifesteal. Something with a defined purpose, like every other effin class. Jack of all trades don't work in a role based game. So basically either drop damage and boost defense, or do the opposite. Also, I don't think energy should be used to cast skills. It should be a different and more so add bonus that differ whether it is above or below the 50%. Energy would be manipulated by weapon skills which could increase energy and utility skills could lower energy. Get rid of natural energy regen, besides energy reset when out of combat. Maybe do low cooldowns on all skills, with a possible ammo system for skills. That way you have enough skills to manipulate energy, enough skills for spikes, but since energy is out for skills you would need some sort of limit for the amount of skills you can use. but no universal resource for it. It's no fun on revenant because it doesn't operate like a thief.
Overall, get rid of resources but still use energy for skill enhancement. I would say make the rev a lifesteal bruiser. Give them more condi cleanse, or condi transfer or something. I like the legends, but make them more similar so they can actually work together. You can't keep all survival skills on one legend. That forces people to take certain legends that take up half the build. It's dumb. Perhaps give the rev only one utility bar where you can set every skill. You still get legends for special effects that you switch between and the trait lines still enhance those legends skills, but don't keep such rigidness in this class. It's no fun. Maybe even make utility skills have an enhanced effect if you're in the correlating legend. you probably can't put all these in the revenant but I think some of these could help out the quality of life.
change renegade's warband into thief's summon. Bam
And I just randomly wrote this within 3secs without even thinking. There are so many fun ways they could had designed it before release but we get this incompetent wells that don't even function like wells.
I would disagree with this. Several classes do the jack of all trades very well. The problem is. Revenant isn't one of those classes. It COULD work in a jack of all trades but it would need work on ALL the legends.
I would say they mostly need tweaks. Ventari and Kalla however. They need a redesign. Ventari needs the whole tablet system removed. It just doesnt work. The healing and all the effects need to be around the Revenant. Kalla should be turned into a Trap/Well/Mark like system, they would all obviously need to be buffed to counter the fact they wouldnt last 10seconds anymore. Though to be fair, most of the skills are kinda crappy and wouldnt be missed much if they were totally redesigned anyway.
Ok... I never played with Revenant but it seems from reading the posts that there are some clear ideas that would make people appreciate this class a lot more.
1) Allow for players to activate/deactivate legendary stances and legend swap, F1 and F2 respectively. There fore, when a legend is not active, players have access to utility skills they can pick from.
2) Allow only the legendary stances to rely on Energy., not the weapon skills
3) Each profession has about 27 slotted skills prior the elite specs, where as Rev has 20. Also, ever other elite spec adds six new slotted skills, while Rev adds 5. These 7 missing skills, plus the racial skills and elite specs skill should be a slotted skill when a legend is not active.
4) The Elite Prof. Mechanics could be F3 for Herald and F3, F4, & F5 for Renegade.
5) The legendary stances would become deactivated when not in combat, but players still commune with one of the two legends and swap legends even when deactivated.
6) Non-Legendary skills will not use energy, will not have any upkeep skills, may be inspired by a legend, but tends to be more of a generic power from the mist.
7) Activating/Deactivating and Swapping Legends while active shares the same cool down, though there is no cool down for legend swapping when legends are deactivated.
8) Deactivated Slotted skills will consist of 1 Healing, 1 Elite, and 5 Utility skills to start, adding a new utility skill for each elite spec.
I think this, aside from balancing issues, is all people are asking for and it seem to be still fitting with the concept of the profession.
Not only that, the game needs some underlying changes to make this work. But I agree, it could work.
One big problem though is that unlike many other MMORPGs, the gear-stats we get aren't locked based on our profession. A jack-of-all-trades would ideally get something like Celestial and be balanced around that. Can't have this in GW2, if we were balanced to work in all Legends based on Celestial, we'd be massively OP if we say, take Viper and run around only as a DPS setup.
On the other hand, this means if we're balanced based on gear picked for a specific role, we're rubbish at all other roles.
I could see this work if each legend has incredibly powerful passive effects and stat-bonuses attached just to being in the legend, and in turn our base power is correspondingly weaker. Granted, in effect that's just a very indirect way of making our gear matter quite a lot less to our final balance, but hey, it'd work. Posted about this before, too. But I can't see ANet make it happen, I feel for as much as the revenant is clearly intended as a jack-of-all-trades char, they're "scared" of implementing it like that, too.
Are you guys serious right now? This is one of the most unique mechanics of the Revenant. I agree with other suggestions on this post, though. Give us more utility options per legend. And I would love if the weapon skills changed with the legend as well, a little like the Elementalist. So a Ventari Staff would be different from a Dwarf Staff. I don't think they would ever go in that direction but... it was my wish.
Come to think of it, would it be so bad if as a class special element, Revenants would not have gear stats? We could equip whatever, the stats are ignored (only runes matter). Stats would be entirely attached to Legends, and we'd be balanced for that amount of stats, so basically we have Zerker in Shiro, Viper in Mallyx, etc?
Plus, it'd be a unique perk: You don't need to get pricey gear, you always have the correct one anyhow.
I think this would be really unbalanced. Imagine running full zerks gear with shiro, and you swap when are low on health, because you are running a healing/toughness/vitality set with venturi which heals to full up while shiro is on cooldown. then swap back and start zerking again.
However this leads into an idea I expressed before. Remove runes from armor and have it as its own thing off to the side - this would also allow for swappable runes sets. Next make minor & major runes more valuable by removing the minor and major portion from the major and superior runes. So each rune grade only has 2 stats. then you only need 3 slots to equip runes - a minor, major and superior slot.
I know that there is a stat increase from the minor group of the minor rune to the minor group of the superior rune. The big question then - is that % difference really important? This might even be something that could translate into PvP - maybe.
So back to @Carighan.6758 thought. If all other professions have a swappable rune set out of combat, maybe with the Revenant - the runes could be linked to the legend. You wouldn't get a crazy overpowered build (not that I can see, but I am bias - its my idea) by just adjusting a few stats from runes, but it would allow for some push and pull with you stats, but not a complete change.
Side note 01: Please make this change. This would allow for Glint and Kalla to be used underwater. Glint should use the ammo system with glyphs and Kalla gets the mobile upkeep skills like glint has now, but with the renegade utilities.
Side note 02: yes having 1 equipped weapon that changes with the legend would be really awesome in theory. implementing would be more difficult. But imagine hammer and staff being a ranged weapon with one legend and melee weapon with another. We would definitely need more utilities for each legend if this happened
Side note 03: Make the Revenant spear as is, a land based weapon for base Rev.
These are some awesome ideas that will never get implemented, unfortunately.
I have my own reservations against this same-old, same-old gear stats thing that is present in absolutely ALL RPGs. I understand that making something different just for the sake of being different can lead to very bad results. I've seen this on my own job, actually. But at the same time I can't believe no-one has ever came up with anything better than these stats attached to armor and gear. +12 Health, +10 Damage, +10 Whatever.
My honest (really, not rhetoric) question to you guys is: is it really fun to kill a bunch of enemies just to get mats for crafting a piece of armor?
The dirty little secret of guild wars 2 balance is that Revenant is already fairly well balanced and designed, while everything else is broken. Rather than a redesign it would be better to just tone down the unfair aspects that other class specs have going for them right now. Engies double stacked 4s stab on 6s CD. Scourges infinite condi application. Mesmers ludicrous survivability/damage balance in general. SB burst. Thief double steal. These are all things that are bad for the game.
Boom, done. Revenant viable with only two small changes to the class itself. Revenant isn't the problem with the current meta, the issue is too many specs have imba kitten that carries them through their mistakes far too much. Revenant doesn't suffer because it is bad, Revenant suffers because it is fair.
Hrm... considering this... you might be right. Post-HoT player power exploded, so that nowadays even open world zones need to throw multiple veterans at us to even make us care enough to use any skills.
An overall nerf to player power might be better than a buff to specific other elements.
Add in some condi cleanse
I am far from an experienced revenant player, but the things that keeps me away from playing it, is the lack of build diversity.
I tend to play around with builds myself, make new things, it's a very large part of this game. Revenant lacks this extremely due to very limited choice in skills. Once I choose a legend, I'm bound to certain skills.
So in order to make revenant more viable add more skills. I understand from a design point, that this isn't the revenant 'feel'. But it's possible to tie skills together. Example: Pain Absorption = Riposting Shadows = Inspiring Reinforcement = ....
New skill = New Skill = New skill = ....
If you get my point...
Redesign and rework one thing and one thing only. Centaur Stance/Ventari's tablet, DO NOT make it a thing that exists in the world, remove that complete, mainstream it like every other skill where it applies itself onto the player whereever the player is.
It's just too difficult to use otherwise.
The shield root needs to go..... when they root 1 skill but make 1 class..... scourge a mobile wall of condis and barrier....
The dwarf stance needs more damage and condi damge reducing.
Slayers [XD] NSP Guild
Yao Chen Herald/Ventari
Ying Wuxian Renegade/Demon
So, looking at the scope of the Mesmer changes, a partial rework seems much more likely than a complete overhaul. Not only that, but it would also be preferable, I think. Personally, I really like the sound of removing the energy cost from weapon skills and adding a fourth utility skill per legend. That approach could be careful and thoughtful enough to constitute a change that's impactful, but not over the top. Two things:
Most of you are ignoring underwater combat. Understandable, but this should still be considered when talking about improving a (and especially this) profession.
What about weapon swap? If Rev's mechanics start functioning in an overall satisfying way, should it stay?
General:
Add 3 glyphs and 3 signets.
Glyphs have effects depending on legend.
Signets dont cost energy.
All utilities (so they dont mess up ventari)
Dwarf:
My changes would concentrate to make jalis pure PbAoE face tank against multiple targets.
Forced Engagement:
Make it AoE 5 targets. Block number of next attacks depending on number of targets hit. (maybe need tweaking for competitive modes)
Inspiring Reinforcement:
Make it PbAoE and circular. Its bound to the rev and also cascades out.
Centaur:
Simple changes to improve play flow.
Remove completely the summon skills.
Remove the tablet destruction from the elite.
Add stunbreak to purifying essence.
Demon:
Make it the Condition "In your Face" legend similar to my idea of Jalis.
Empowering mysery:
Consumes conditions on you.
Banish Enchantment:
Change it to AoE. Instead of applying confusion it transfers conditions from you to your targets.
Shiro and Glint seem fine to me.
Kalla i dont know. I dont play renegade.
I would put a huge disclaimer on the character creation screen that warns new players about the extra effort/execution/resource management rev'ing takes to filter out all the players who just want "Dragonhunter/Warrior, but with an edgier theme!!!!11.1!"
For me the simplest approach is to add one or two skills to each legend, giving players SOME choice as to what skills they take in their bars. Adding skills is the easiest way to address some of the deficiencies.
Abuse from people that tell you how to play is not a reason to change a class in a game that is designed and works to allow you to play how you want.
Weaver-like mixing of Legends? I mean, we do get twice the number of utilities thanks to Legend swaps, but it's annoying when you need just one skill from a particular Legend and end up using the whole line. Of course, I don't expect it to happen, and honestly, we don't need multiple-personality disorder added to our list of woes, but I think it's high time we had an overhaul. I love my Rev but it's very frustrating to know how much more we have to do to get the same effect as another profession. Feels unfair. If Mesmer is supposed to be Anet's baby, I sometimes feel like Rev's the stepchild.
start removing energy cost from weapon skills and work from there...u dont need to start with sweeping changes , but slowly to see what works and what doesnt