Jump to content
  • Sign Up

Template interactions initial thoughts and POST YO LINKS \(o.o)/ thread


Daniel Handler.4816

Recommended Posts

@Daniel Handler.4816 said:Switching to builds that need to hide/portal in WvW is easier (will edit in link) Mimic is very bugged when using it and swapping to builds that don't have it and back. And Chrono is definitely not getting CS dry shatter back. Also. Gimme dem links.

we have 2 builds, and since I play both PvE and PvP its a net lose for me. templates succ, big gem sink not gonna pay for them, thank you very much!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

@Leonidrex.5649 said:

@Daniel Handler.4816 said:Switching to builds that need to hide/portal in WvW is easier (will edit in link) Mimic is very bugged when using it and swapping to builds that don't have it and back. And Chrono is definitely not getting CS dry shatter back. Also. Gimme dem links.

we have 2 builds, and since I play both PvE and PvP its a net lose for me. templates succ, big gem sink not gonna pay for them, thank you very much!

You have three! Remember to buy the free one in gem shop! Net gains!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

@Daniel Handler.4816 said:

@Daniel Handler.4816 said:Switching to builds that need to hide/portal in WvW is easier (will edit in link) Mimic is very bugged when using it and swapping to builds that don't have it and back. And Chrono is definitely not getting CS dry shatter back. Also. Gimme dem links.

we have 2 builds, and since I play both PvE and PvP its a net lose for me. templates succ, big gem sink not gonna pay for them, thank you very much!

You have three! Remember to buy the free one in gem shop! Net gains!

I ment the weapon set ones, only got 2.since i run both cmira power chrono/core. an supp chrono those are at least 4 different weapon sets. :/

Link to comment
Share on other sites

@"Curunen.8729" said:Wait, can you switch anywhere out of combat in wvw?

I hope it's restricted to spawn only or we're really going to end up in "Build Wars".I certainly don't. Mesmer is pressured into running non-combat worthy utility more than most other classes. The build we use to perma alacrity on siege is far worse than the renegade counterpart. This is a massive QoL buff.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

@Leonidrex.5649 said:

@Daniel Handler.4816 said:Switching to builds that need to hide/portal in WvW is easier (will edit in link) Mimic is very bugged when using it and swapping to builds that don't have it and back. And Chrono is definitely not getting CS dry shatter back. Also. Gimme dem links.

we have 2 builds, and since I play both PvE and PvP its a net lose for me. templates succ, big gem sink not gonna pay for them, thank you very much!

You have three! Remember to buy the free one in gem shop! Net gains!

I ment the weapon set ones, only got 2.since i run both cmira power chrono/core. an supp chrono those are at least 4 different weapon sets. :/

Still don't see how you lost anything. Unless you meant you are using different weapon sets in WvW, PvP and PvE. But weapon sets didn't auto switch anyway so it is still a gain.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

@Daniel Handler.4816 said:

@"Curunen.8729" said:Wait, can you switch anywhere out of combat in wvw?

I hope it's restricted to spawn only or we're really going to end up in "Build Wars".I certainly don't. Mesmer is pressured into running non-combat worthy utility more than most other classes. The build we use to perma alacrity on siege is far worse than the renegade counterpart. This is a massive QoL buff.

I have been informed by a friend who's guildmate I also play with occasionally (a solid guardian) that they can prebuff themselves in a different template to 30s quickness before swapping and engaging in a different spec, eg DH.

It's possible to do things like engage in torch stealth with PU before swapping template to two completely different weapons such as pistol and greatsword.

This is scratching the surface to what kind of insane pre combat setup or out of combat instant swap to hardcounter potential there could be.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

@Daniel Handler.4816 said:

@Daniel Handler.4816 said:Switching to builds that need to hide/portal in WvW is easier (will edit in link) Mimic is very bugged when using it and swapping to builds that don't have it and back. And Chrono is definitely not getting CS dry shatter back. Also. Gimme dem links.

we have 2 builds, and since I play both PvE and PvP its a net lose for me. templates succ, big gem sink not gonna pay for them, thank you very much!

You have three! Remember to buy the free one in gem shop! Net gains!

I ment the weapon set ones, only got 2.since i run both cmira power chrono/core. an supp chrono those are at least 4 different weapon sets. :/

Still don't see how you lost anything. Unless you meant you are using different weapon sets in WvW, PvP and PvE. But weapon sets didn't auto switch anyway so it is still a gain.

I gain nothing out of the system, only thing that changed is the fact that i have to change builds between pvp and pve, and after pvp ends im in pve with pvp build, if it puts me in combat its really annoying

Link to comment
Share on other sites

@Curunen.8729 said:

@Curunen.8729 said:Wait, can you switch anywhere out of combat in wvw?

I hope it's restricted to spawn only or we're really going to end up in "Build Wars".I certainly don't. Mesmer is pressured into running non-combat worthy utility more than most other classes. The build we use to perma alacrity on siege is far worse than the renegade counterpart. This is a massive QoL buff.

I have been informed by a friend who's guildmate I also play with occasionally (a solid guardian) that they can prebuff themselves in a different template to 30s quickness before swapping and engaging in a different spec, eg DH.

It's possible to do things like engage in torch stealth with PU before swapping template to two completely different weapons such as pistol and greatsword.

This is scratching the surface to what kind of insane pre combat setup or out of combat instant swap to hardcounter potential there could be.

I'm not concerned with people being able to pre-use skills when they put their slots on cooldown.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

@Leonidrex.5649 said:

@Daniel Handler.4816 said:Switching to builds that need to hide/portal in WvW is easier (will edit in link) Mimic is very bugged when using it and swapping to builds that don't have it and back. And Chrono is definitely not getting CS dry shatter back. Also. Gimme dem links.

we have 2 builds, and since I play both PvE and PvP its a net lose for me. templates succ, big gem sink not gonna pay for them, thank you very much!

You have three! Remember to buy the free one in gem shop! Net gains!

I ment the weapon set ones, only got 2.since i run both cmira power chrono/core. an supp chrono those are at least 4 different weapon sets. :/

Still don't see how you lost anything. Unless you meant you are using different weapon sets in WvW, PvP and PvE. But weapon sets didn't auto switch anyway so it is still a gain.

I gain nothing out of the system, only thing that changed is the fact that i have to change builds between pvp and pve, and after pvp ends im in pve with pvp build, if it puts me in combat its really annoying

You gain the ability to share you builds and adopt others without having to manually copy all traits.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

@Daniel Handler.4816 said:

@Daniel Handler.4816 said:Switching to builds that need to hide/portal in WvW is easier (will edit in link) Mimic is very bugged when using it and swapping to builds that don't have it and back. And Chrono is definitely not getting CS dry shatter back. Also. Gimme dem links.

we have 2 builds, and since I play both PvE and PvP its a net lose for me. templates succ, big gem sink not gonna pay for them, thank you very much!

You have three! Remember to buy the free one in gem shop! Net gains!

I ment the weapon set ones, only got 2.since i run both cmira power chrono/core. an supp chrono those are at least 4 different weapon sets. :/

Still don't see how you lost anything. Unless you meant you are using different weapon sets in WvW, PvP and PvE. But weapon sets didn't auto switch anyway so it is still a gain.

I gain nothing out of the system, only thing that changed is the fact that i have to change builds between pvp and pve, and after pvp ends im in pve with pvp build, if it puts me in combat its really annoying

You gain the ability to share you builds and adopt others without having to manually copy all traits.

I had the ability to do that already, by typing.now i have ability to get fucked over by swamp of lab monsters becouse my pvp build is bad in pve.It might be me making builds like this in league but making build in gw2 from scratch ( trait wise ) takes me 10-15s max

Link to comment
Share on other sites

@Leonidrex.5649 said:

@Daniel Handler.4816 said:Switching to builds that need to hide/portal in WvW is easier (will edit in link) Mimic is very bugged when using it and swapping to builds that don't have it and back. And Chrono is definitely not getting CS dry shatter back. Also. Gimme dem links.

we have 2 builds, and since I play both PvE and PvP its a net lose for me. templates succ, big gem sink not gonna pay for them, thank you very much!

You have three! Remember to buy the free one in gem shop! Net gains!

I ment the weapon set ones, only got 2.since i run both cmira power chrono/core. an supp chrono those are at least 4 different weapon sets. :/

Still don't see how you lost anything. Unless you meant you are using different weapon sets in WvW, PvP and PvE. But weapon sets didn't auto switch anyway so it is still a gain.

I gain nothing out of the system, only thing that changed is the fact that i have to change builds between pvp and pve, and after pvp ends im in pve with pvp build, if it puts me in combat its really annoying

You gain the ability to share you builds and adopt others without having to manually copy all traits.

I had the ability to do that already, by typing.now i have ability to get kitten over by swamp of lab monsters becouse my pvp build is bad in pve.It might be me making builds like this in league but making build in gw2 from scratch ( trait wise ) takes me 10-15s max

If you are able to change builds that fast without abusing a macro I commend your speed. But other people are not. Especially when you add in stat selecting.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

@Daniel Handler.4816 said:

@Curunen.8729 said:Wait, can you switch anywhere out of combat in wvw?

I hope it's restricted to spawn only or we're really going to end up in "Build Wars".I certainly don't. Mesmer is pressured into running non-combat worthy utility more than most other classes. The build we use to perma alacrity on siege is far worse than the renegade counterpart. This is a massive QoL buff.

I have been informed by a friend who's guildmate I also play with occasionally (a solid guardian) that they can prebuff themselves in a different template to 30s quickness before swapping and engaging in a different spec, eg DH.

It's possible to do things like engage in torch stealth with PU before swapping template to two completely different weapons such as pistol and greatsword.

This is scratching the surface to what kind of insane pre combat setup or out of combat instant swap to hardcounter potential there could be.

I'm not concerned with people being able to pre-use skills when they put their slots on cooldown.

Weapon skills don't go on cooldown, neither are any traited skill interactions even if utility slots do go on cooldown. Longer lasting effects make certain utility cooldowns minor inconvenience compared with the advantage given.

In my opinion there are too many potential broken interactions affecting combat for this to not be reevaluated as soon as possible.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

@Curunen.8729 said:

@Curunen.8729 said:Wait, can you switch anywhere out of combat in wvw?

I hope it's restricted to spawn only or we're really going to end up in "Build Wars".I certainly don't. Mesmer is pressured into running non-combat worthy utility more than most other classes. The build we use to perma alacrity on siege is far worse than the renegade counterpart. This is a massive QoL buff.

I have been informed by a friend who's guildmate I also play with occasionally (a solid guardian) that they can prebuff themselves in a different template to 30s quickness before swapping and engaging in a different spec, eg DH.

It's possible to do things like engage in torch stealth with PU before swapping template to two completely different weapons such as pistol and greatsword.

This is scratching the surface to what kind of insane pre combat setup or out of combat instant swap to hardcounter potential there could be.

I'm not concerned with people being able to pre-use skills when they put their slots on cooldown.

Weapon skills don't go on cooldown, neither are any traited skill interactions even if utility slots do go on cooldown. Longer lasting effects make certain utility cooldowns minor inconvenience compared with the advantage given.

In my opinion there are too many potential broken interactions affecting combat for this to not be reevaluated as soon as possible.

Weapon skills do go on cooldown last time I checked. Disabling skill 4 on one of your sets for torch's cooldown is an inconvenience, regardless of whether you get +1 second from prismatic. The only potentially broken thing right now is engie toolbelts and kits aren't having their cooldowns impacted at all.

edit: I don't care if a guardian can put most of their bar on cooldown to gain quickness if mesmer doesn't have to get stuck on wells/signets every time it wants to give a meaningful amount of alacrity.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

@Daniel Handler.4816 said:

@Curunen.8729 said:Wait, can you switch anywhere out of combat in wvw?

I hope it's restricted to spawn only or we're really going to end up in "Build Wars".I certainly don't. Mesmer is pressured into running non-combat worthy utility more than most other classes. The build we use to perma alacrity on siege is far worse than the renegade counterpart. This is a massive QoL buff.

I have been informed by a friend who's guildmate I also play with occasionally (a solid guardian) that they can prebuff themselves in a different template to 30s quickness before swapping and engaging in a different spec, eg DH.

It's possible to do things like engage in torch stealth with PU before swapping template to two completely different weapons such as pistol and greatsword.

This is scratching the surface to what kind of insane pre combat setup or out of combat instant swap to hardcounter potential there could be.

I'm not concerned with people being able to pre-use skills when they put their slots on cooldown.

Weapon skills don't go on cooldown, neither are any traited skill interactions even if utility slots do go on cooldown. Longer lasting effects make certain utility cooldowns minor inconvenience compared with the advantage given.

In my opinion there are too many potential broken interactions affecting combat for this to not be reevaluated as soon as possible.

Weapon skills do go on cooldown last time I checked. Disabling skill 4 on one of your sets for torch's cooldown is an inconvenience, regardless of whether you get +1 second from prismatic. The only potentially broken thing right now is engie toolbelts and kits aren't having their cooldowns impacted at all.

edit: I don't care if a guardian can put most of their bar on cooldown to gain quickness if mesmer doesn't have to get stuck on wells/signets every time it wants to give a meaningful amount of alacrity.

Well somehow I'm able to torch 4 on a PU template and swap to two different weapons both with skill 4 off cooldown. Or cast staff 5 at feet and swap again with both other skill 5 off cooldown. Effectively I can use skills and trait synergies from a third weapon if its cast effects persist, while swapping template.

It's been a long day so I apologise if being blunt about this and can appreciate your new freedom with chrono, but regardless I stand by the opinion this is going to be abused - just a matter of time to see how creative people get with different classes and groups.

The one way I could accept this as a feature is if all active effects and placed skills (aoes, traps etc) were instantly dispelled on template swap - which could solve both our issues.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

@Curunen.8729 said:

@Curunen.8729 said:Wait, can you switch anywhere out of combat in wvw?

I hope it's restricted to spawn only or we're really going to end up in "Build Wars".I certainly don't. Mesmer is pressured into running non-combat worthy utility more than most other classes. The build we use to perma alacrity on siege is far worse than the renegade counterpart. This is a massive QoL buff.

I have been informed by a friend who's guildmate I also play with occasionally (a solid guardian) that they can prebuff themselves in a different template to 30s quickness before swapping and engaging in a different spec, eg DH.

It's possible to do things like engage in torch stealth with PU before swapping template to two completely different weapons such as pistol and greatsword.

This is scratching the surface to what kind of insane pre combat setup or out of combat instant swap to hardcounter potential there could be.

I'm not concerned with people being able to pre-use skills when they put their slots on cooldown.

Weapon skills don't go on cooldown, neither are any traited skill interactions even if utility slots do go on cooldown. Longer lasting effects make certain utility cooldowns minor inconvenience compared with the advantage given.

In my opinion there are too many potential broken interactions affecting combat for this to not be reevaluated as soon as possible.

Weapon skills do go on cooldown last time I checked. Disabling skill 4 on one of your sets for torch's cooldown is an inconvenience, regardless of whether you get +1 second from prismatic. The only potentially broken thing right now is engie toolbelts and kits aren't having their cooldowns impacted at all.

edit: I don't care if a guardian can put most of their bar on cooldown to gain quickness if mesmer doesn't have to get stuck on wells/signets every time it wants to give a meaningful amount of alacrity.

Well somehow I'm able to torch 4 on a PU template and swap to two different weapons both with skill 4 off cooldown. Or cast staff 5 at feet and swap again with both other skill 5 off cooldown. Effectively I can use skills and trait synergies from a third weapon if its cast effects persist, while swapping template.

It's been a long day so I apologise if being blunt about this and can appreciate your new freedom with chrono, but regardless I stand by the opinion this is going to be abused - just a matter of time to see how creative people get with different classes and groups.

The one way I could accept this as a feature is if all active effects and placed skills (aoes, traps etc) were instantly dispelled on template swap - which could solve both our issues.

That's a bug not a feature. I sometimes get that, and sometimes I don't. Only the heal slot seems to be properly transfering cds. For instance expending two jaunts and swapping builds to a different elite will put the new one on a 60 second cooldown.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

@Daniel Handler.4816 said:

@Curunen.8729 said:Wait, can you switch anywhere out of combat in wvw?

I hope it's restricted to spawn only or we're really going to end up in "Build Wars".I certainly don't. Mesmer is pressured into running non-combat worthy utility more than most other classes. The build we use to perma alacrity on siege is far worse than the renegade counterpart. This is a massive QoL buff.

I have been informed by a friend who's guildmate I also play with occasionally (a solid guardian) that they can prebuff themselves in a different template to 30s quickness before swapping and engaging in a different spec, eg DH.

It's possible to do things like engage in torch stealth with PU before swapping template to two completely different weapons such as pistol and greatsword.

This is scratching the surface to what kind of insane pre combat setup or out of combat instant swap to hardcounter potential there could be.

I'm not concerned with people being able to pre-use skills when they put their slots on cooldown.

Weapon skills don't go on cooldown, neither are any traited skill interactions even if utility slots do go on cooldown. Longer lasting effects make certain utility cooldowns minor inconvenience compared with the advantage given.

In my opinion there are too many potential broken interactions affecting combat for this to not be reevaluated as soon as possible.

Weapon skills do go on cooldown last time I checked. Disabling skill 4 on one of your sets for torch's cooldown is an inconvenience, regardless of whether you get +1 second from prismatic. The only potentially broken thing right now is engie toolbelts and kits aren't having their cooldowns impacted at all.

edit: I don't care if a guardian can put most of their bar on cooldown to gain quickness if mesmer doesn't have to get stuck on wells/signets every time it wants to give a meaningful amount of alacrity.

Well somehow I'm able to torch 4 on a PU template and swap to two different weapons both with skill 4 off cooldown. Or cast staff 5 at feet and swap again with both other skill 5 off cooldown. Effectively I can use skills and trait synergies from a third weapon if its cast effects persist, while swapping template.

It's been a long day so I apologise if being blunt about this and can appreciate your new freedom with chrono, but regardless I stand by the opinion this is going to be abused - just a matter of time to see how creative people get with different classes and groups.

The one way I could accept this as a feature is if all active effects and placed skills (aoes, traps etc) were instantly dispelled on template swap - which could solve both our issues.

That's a bug not a feature. I sometimes get that, and sometimes I don't. Only the heal slot seems to be properly transfering cds. For instance expending two jaunts and swapping builds to a different elite will put the new one on a 60 second cooldown.

Utilities and elite slots do share cooldown as far as I'm aware. But all combinations of weapon skills, as long as you swap to a different weapon type, the new weapon skills will be off cooldown.If this is a bug then they need to fix it asap.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It's not a bug and certainly doesn't need fixing. Why should using staff #5 mean that u can't use pistol #5 when you weapon swap? That's nonsensical. If you have staff/staff then using any weapon skill will have it's cd transferred when you swap to the same weapon- can you imagine the ridiculousness of skill slots sharing a cd with ele for example? If i have 2 templates which share weapons/utilites, i'd expect that using a skill in one template would affect the cd of the same skill in a different template if i swapped them.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

@Funky.4861 said:It's not a bug and certainly doesn't need fixing. Why should using staff #5 mean that u can't use pistol #5 when you weapon swap? That's nonsensical. If you have staff/staff then using any weapon skill will have it's cd transferred when you swap to the same weapon- can you imagine the ridiculousness of skill slots sharing a cd with ele for example? If i have 2 templates which share weapons/utilites, i'd expect that using a skill in one template would affect the cd of the same skill in a different template if i swapped them.

I know it's not a bug...

The problem is before, changing gear stats, skills, traits, weapons etc took a certain amount of time. Aside from the odd change or swapping in and out a weapon (eg focus for swiftness on 4), there isn't time for the kind of deep customisation that is now possible at the touch of a button.This allows certain comboing and prebuffing to a fairly significant extent between more than one build at the start and also if managing to kite in and out of combat.

One solution I think that could solve the problem is simply adding a flat 1 minute cooldown to Equipment Template swap, and maybe 30s cooldown to Build Template swap in wvw.

Ideally though it would be amazing if there was a swap cooldown that varied with the number of changes in gear/traits/skills - so a single different trait could cause a 5s swap cooldown, but an entire change of gear stats could push it up to 1 minute etc. But I think that is way too complicated a system.

So yeah, just like they added 5 second cooldown to warclaw mount/dismount, there should be a similar cooldown to template swap in wvw - the length is up for argument.

Pve of course it doesn't matter.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

WvW is pve as far as dev's are concerned, and i'm strongly against any such cd in swapping templates/traits/whatever. Before the change, our raid squad would have a little break as people swapped gear and traits from say DH to condi quickbrand; now, it's just a couple of clicks and we're good to go. I don't want a return to hanging around while other people change their char to suit the encounter, and anet seem reluctant to split wvw from pve (i assume the effort:reward ratio is a loss).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If they can add a cooldown to warclaw compared with pve mounts, I'd imagine it's not too much of a stretch to have some kind of similar limitation with template swap in wvw.

Aside from the legendary gear issues with swapping stuff within a template resetting and removing upgrades etc, I don't mind if as before players want to modify gear/traits/skills manually at any time out of combat. But when things like for example power thief runs into I dunno, a bunker or hardcounter of some sort - ports out of combat, instant swap and immediately reengages on condi (a process that may take more time before, but now can be done without giving the opponent much breathing room) - I find this, and other of the many possibilities template swap allows, to not be healthy for the game. Especially as it incentivises having several templates ready to be optimal, to counter different things. Even if at this point one can say the game mode has already been far from healthy, I don't feel it's helping the situation.

Anyway I think it's just a matter of time before the true potential of template swapping in wvw is taken advantage of, so we'll just have to wait and see what happens - hopefully the impact remains small and I am wrong.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

They added a cd to mounts in pve long before they even added warclaw; you used to be able to instantaneously swap say from bunny to griffon (even mid-air) but that was too much apparently so they added a cd to remounting which ended that possibility. For the warclaw, they just extended the duration. As long as wvw doesn't become template wars, we should be fine, as anyone can swap builds in seconds.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

@Funky.4861 said:They added a cd to mounts in pve long before they even added warclaw; you used to be able to instantaneously swap say from bunny to griffon (even mid-air) but that was too much apparently so they added a cd to remounting which ended that possibility. For the warclaw, they just extended the duration. As long as wvw doesn't become template wars, we should be fine, as anyone can swap builds in seconds.

Oh, thanks I wasn't aware of that regarding mount cooldowns.

For templates - still can do in less than a second now what could take many more seconds if changing all gear pieces, traits and weapons. As said I'm planning at least one template for dedicated PU stealth stack cheese for engage (precast skills etc and swap before in combat) or teleport out of combat and disengage, a second template for high power burst + mobility to unload and get back out of combat, and third hybrid bruiser. Possibly more depending on the people I play with and what synergies - eg a friend can keep someone in combat while I pull out swap and jump back in for burst kill etc.

So personally I feel pressured to buy more Equipment Templates, but going to wait in the hope that there is a sale before the end of the year, or that Anet to some extent disincentivise this kind of play.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

That's the very thing- those who would benefit the most from templates are feeling pressured into buying more (at quite a high price imo) whereas those who only have 1 or 2 builds per char basically get a freebie and are less likely to explore other game modes/build diversity on that char because their existing 'template' will be overwritten.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...