The Next Elite Spec; What Is Engineer Missing?
rrusse.7058
Member ✭✭
The Engineer has a decent array of skills, abilities and builds and I've been wondering what is missing from the Engineer's capabilities. Rather than try and propose what the next elite spec should be based off of a concept of what seems cool, I wanted to think about it in terms of how Arenanet goes about designing elite specializations. By going off of what a profession is lacking and how it would benefit the profession as a whole.
Personally I feel the profession lacks a dedicated support/team role that can be used effectively in WvW and raids specifically. There are DPS and tanking options, but I feel there is some room for improvement in the area I mentioned.
Where does the rest of the Engineer playing community stand though? I'm interested in hearing what others feel the profession needs or would like to see.
Comments
This won't be a fun answer, but I personally hope they don't develop another e-spec and use the energy to revamp core specs. There are tons for fun builds, across all professions, that the core game had that are just unplayable now. Let's get some remediation and build diversity before we expand again.
Answering your question would be easier if Scrapper had a defined niche. As it stands it's one of the weakest if not the weakest overall elite spec and most of the reason why it is like that comes in the form of not having a set identity outside trying to mimic a "tank" in a game where tanking has little value outside very specific scenarios.
Their class mechanic (gyros in general) serve no meaningful purpose too, imo.
Minstrels Support scrapper is one of the most common engineer builds in WvW zergs currently and it's very good. Even if it's not good in raids I don't think we need a second support style build considering the lack in other areas, like reliable long range damage.
Holo is simplified burst melee, core engineer can do melee/mid range dmg well with both condi and power, scrapper is tanky and supplements core support traits to make a good healing/tank build (even though the rest of scrapper is trash mostly).
Reliable boonstrip. Mine and minefield remove boons, but have long cooldowns.
The concept of dedicated support scares me nowadays. I'm not going to lie.
Disgruntled Charr Engineer and Pirate - Jade Quarry
Engineer is definitively missing a few things:
All of the other potential builds can be played if you know what you're doing, but these particular aspects are missing.
From this, I can actually picture a "Soundsmith" or "Sonic Striker" or similar archetype of engineer that uses sound as a weapon.
The great god Lagki demands sacrifice!
supply crate is the elite turret skill
I Have No friends, so I Must pug
I'm aware. It's also not an elite turret.
The great god Lagki demands sacrifice!
That's pretty interesting to think about. In particular I am interested in mention of Engineer lacking AoE buffs and not having a good way to strip boons. Perhaps there is some room for some sort of Saboteur? Maybe the next spec doesn't have to go the route of being a support based spec and it could be one that tries to punish enemies and reward players with correct positioning and attacking while also granting those benefits to allies?
I keep imagining something like the Spellbreaker, but does more than just cast a bubble and run back out again. The theme of a sound based profession could work too as it still fits in lore with the dredge and even Scarlet and her machinations.
I'd like a long range nuker elite spec. Longbow with laser abilities. Huge laser attack that is a large destructive AOE. Multiple thin lasers zig zagging or curving in the air to hit foes. Launching a bomb and detonating it high in the air to shower an area with laser bombardments.
I am honestly really happy with engi, the one thing lacking was reliable stab and I feel last update helped with this issue. Core engi lacks sustain and still very weak to ranged attacks. The melee damage could use some help, maybe make tool kit the melee kit and give it some much needed damage.
Thematically I rly want the devs to explore explosives and rockets on engie more.
i don't really see how you can expand explosives on engi seeing how explosives make up a large part of core engi
I Have No friends, so I Must pug
i guess the core part of engie consists of alot of explosives but i defo think theres alot of explore in terms of niches. I also think tis a very fitting theme for engie
my question was what those niches are
I Have No friends, so I Must pug
Anything that can fit in an elite spec? I really dont see where it doesnt fit in.
M8, i'm not saying that it doesn't fit, i'm asking what "it" is. Because i can't come up with an explosive theme that's strong enough to carry an elite spec and isn't core explosives.
I Have No friends, so I Must pug
I feel like its a matter of taste.. and imagination. Maybe the reason you can't come up with something with an explosives theme is because you dont want to? Explosives bow spec, explosive staff spec. Maybe the reason why I cna come up with ideas for explosive specs is because I realy want one? Hmm. I really do wanna hear what kind of e-spec you want tho, that isnt explovies
Explosive bow/staff isn't a new theme, that's the same theme on a new weapon.
A few suggestions i've heard with potential was technomancer and sound engineer
I Have No friends, so I Must pug
Question here the Gyro is useful? I am not seeing anyone using it
Biggest complaint seems to be the AI
I Have No friends, so I Must pug
Staff elite, engineer is massively lacking Non Projectile AoE , as well as boon strip and proper boon application , the boon turret trait is a decent idea but unfortunetly turrets are absolute garbage , also stationary .
Bomb kit?
Throw mine has boon strip and it isn't used that often, the tool kit ability throws out 5 and can be remotely detonated. The regular ability also has a blast finisher and knock back, great fun for knocking people off keep walls. Has great range and can be thrown on top of them I found with much enjoyment. It is also really fun to mess with zergs, hardly a game changing ability though. Boon corrupt is really strong as is winds, it stops new boons (aegis which also heals when traited) and projectiles, the boon strip isn't what makes those abilities great.
Net, rifle and rocket turrets need updated. I would love a portal ability that lets me summon my turrets similar to ritualist ability. A portal gun or mode similar to holo forge would be awesome. I really enjoyed ritualist weapon skills, skill that make allies weapons look really cool and get new abilities or possibly our own rifle go full auto like a gatling gun.
Duration based unblockable buff would be nice. Like Unstoppable_Union_(effect)
Maybe even share it with nearby allies.
Weapon swap!!
Last two elite specs:
Next elite spec:
I actually love the E-specs. Sure it takes time away from old core builds but it interjects new life into a profession and opens up new playstyles. Core stuff can always be buffed via patches, which they do do from time to time. But I can promise you sales would likely drop for a new expansion if it just focused on core material. People want new toys when they buy expansions. Afterall, not everyone is involved in Endgame level story content.
As for what the profession could use, I want a second long range combat outside of rifle. We've gotten two melee specs and they're lots of fun but I'd also like to be up to blow stuff up at a distance with something other than the rifle.
Engi clearly needs an espec focused on condis
Simple: A GATLING BAZOOKA, HOVER SHOES, PERMA-SUPSERSPEED BUILD WITH HOT-BLOODED, THROAT-BLEEDING, BATTLE-SCREAMING ACTION!!!
And the 'kung-fu' grip.
Edit:
And we get this playing in the background whenever we fight -
Im hoping for a staff engineer that uses ‘nanobots’ (purely flavour text, no AI nonsense) to inflict debilitating conditions onto the enemy from the inside out. Staff skills play with Nanotech idea and are themed around Electrical AoEs.
Due to the fact these nanobots are ‘inside’ the enemy’ bloodstream, maybe a few of the soft cc debuffs could be uncleansable.
F-skills replace the toolkit and allow the Engie to have an array of nanobots deployable at all times.
Utility type: Nanotech
Heal skill = Low initial heal paired with rapid regen over 8s as the Nanomachines mend you from within.
I’d post more but I don’t want my post too long.
I'm firm with the reliable long range damage as the next elite spec, preferably power too since engineer's have a lot of options for conditions already with pistols and kits, even if they aren't new condi's aren't really lacking so I'd say some power damage. My first idea which I've posted before was a longbow, 1200 range with different arrow tips for damage and weapon augments (like thief venoms but physical instead of conditions) like a magnetic augment that would pull nearby foes to the enemy you hit when applied.
I got another idea now too with Staff for those of you who like that weapon. This one would be a power DoT spec with a burst attack you can access by consuming the DoT's applied. I don't really have all the specifics made up but basically you'd have a staff auto which would be a 3 chain set up, first two attacks fire laser bolts at the enemy and the final attack fires a shredder bolt which basically would apply a very small damage but long duration DoT, similar effect to how a thief's pulmonary impact works, just over time. the other staff skills would have some other power DoT abilities too, maybe with some extra effect on the first impact since power DoT really isn't interesting on its own. then the 5 skill would be a ammo skill that consumes the DoT's for a burst that scales with how many DoT's were applied.
You'd have to hit the initial strike for any of the DoT's to apply of course and since there would be a lot of power DoT's they would not be unblockable and any damage mitigating effects would apply to the DoT's as well (so like weakness could cause glances and dodging would evade them and the damage would be blocked as well.
Just an idea I had for something different that we haven't seen, since pretty much all power damage is actively striking except a few skills (like Ray of Judgement).
Personally out of theme I like my longbow with arrow tips idea better but this one has an interesting concept IMO.
I was thinking this only a few days ago, that adding boon strip to bunker down would be ideal. Then with gadgeteer traited thrown mine and sigil of annulment, you'd have a fair bit going on.
If that's not enough for you, it could be reasoned that analyse foe (goggles toolbelt skill) would be a good thematic fit for 1x boon removal and also continues on the gadget theme, which could do with the attention.
Sparkr's Wonderful World of Engineering - https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCEONFRaJV2u2f12ytXEir9A
There can't really be a condi elite spec without heavy core condi nerfs since condi engi is in a solid spot now.
I would prefer a support spec as new elite. One that focusses on buffs instead of healing to have finally some competition on that role. Currently chrono is the only profession able to provide quickness + alacrity. Would be nice to have more than one profession being able to do that.
Should limit healing output though since having boons + heal on one build would be way too op.
I just want a dagger with screw driver skin.
im thinking next espec might be similar to scourge considering what engi lacks.
you don't know till you know, ya know.
https://en-forum.guildwars2.com/discussion/80435/another-meaningless-nerf-list/p1?new=1
Dual wield screwdriver (dagger) and/or spanner/hammer (mace)
Either could work with offhand pistol
Sparkr's Wonderful World of Engineering - https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCEONFRaJV2u2f12ytXEir9A
I had a thought on this last night...
Heavy Weaponist
Loses access to kits, all f# skills are replaced with heavy weapons.
Example: f1 - rocket launcher: all weapon skills are replaced with (none-ground) targetted arcing prjectiles (not as long range or high arcing as mortar). Rocket: an area blast (20% chance finisher) auto attack, bunker buster: an armour piercing missile, incendiary missile clues in the name,** multiple rocket pod** (channelled single target small missiles), chaff launcher (defensive aoe blind and smoke field) and seeker missile (lond cd powerful missile with big telegraph).
f2 could be mini gun, short range cone firing style, f3 power gaultlets for melee range low dmg high cc, f4
Sparkr's Wonderful World of Engineering - https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCEONFRaJV2u2f12ytXEir9A
I'd like to see something focused around either turrets, a "mini drone army" or power suits.
Am i the only one who wants to use the next Elite spec as an opportunity to expand our abilities as a reliable Healer?
The recent Med Kit rework was a mark to the right step, and i think it only needs a little push that could integrate the reamining missing aspects of a great support build (dmg coeficient buffs, boon spread, healing boosts, you name it).
Even if this e-spec wasn't at the mark of druid usefulness, at least reach to a decent firebrand support tier in terms of versatility for the team.
A healing focused engineer wouldnt really be interesting unless it was a RNG boon alchemist imo. At that point just buff elixirs.
I am seeing a staff lighting focused high range and damage espec.
If i had to bet this would be it.
I would really be pissed if it was healing or something ai like turrets or gyros.
i would love to see that they add a new weapon for all base classes...
And a new set of traits and utillity skills
Not with the next expansion.. (expansions are for elite specs)
But with the release of season 5...
This indeed would be the right moment to do so...
I would be nice if the engineer could get a new utility skills in every cattegory.. and finally a gadget elite...
As weapon i would love to see a long bow...
Yea plz do this.
I disagree.
Core condi is unnecessarily complicated for the value it brings. If getting a sane condi spec requires razing core condi to the ground: so be it it.
How about some mace-swinging support engi?
Artificer:
The artificer uses ley-infused crystals as cores for small machinations that allow him to alter himself and his surroundings (think signets)
Mainhand weapon would be a mace with a ley-infused core.
The #1 rota would consist of 2 swings that cause linear aoe's in a short to medium range in front of him, and a 3rd to cause cripple for 2 seconds in the same area. The first 2 hits inflict the unique condition "ley-radiated", which in itself does damage similar to poison, lasts for 3 seconds and can be cleaned by normal means.
The #2 skill pulls all enemies in a 1.2k range who are currently ley-radiated towards the engi. All Targets within 240 range will receive ley-radiated and blind.
The #3 skill is a blast-finisher & inflicts burning and confusion on any target in a 240 range. Lay-radiated targets get additionally rooted for a short time.
This weapon can be combined with shield or pistol, and should synergize well with both.
Utilities:
Crystal Cores work similar to signets, in that they grant unique buffs to the wearer and offer offensive use upon activation. Additionally Crystal Cores block their corresponding Toolbelt-Skill with an aura that grants supportive effects to allies, who mirror the Actual Crystal Core to a lesser degree. Ofc these shut down too once a Core goes on cd.
Healing-Skill
Life-Core
Off cd: Pulses Healing equal to 3 times regeneration (scales with healingpower like regeneration) to the engi.
Toolbelt: Pulses regeneration to allies
Activation: Projects a waterfield. Syphons life from enemies in 480 range. Inflicts direct damage equal to 20% of the engineers total health to enemies. Heals the engi as much as total damage dealt. Allies in range receive 15% of dealt damage as healing, too
Utility
Speed-Core
Off cd: Pulses a unique form of superspeed to the engi that only increases his movement-speed, not his attack speed. Ignores cripple and immobilize, but can still be pulled / knocked around
Toolbelt: Pulses swiftness to allies.
Activation: Stun-breaker. Projects a smoke-field. Grants superspeed to the engi and cripples enemies in a 480 range. Ley-radiated targets get immobilized. Consumes Lay-radiation
Light-Core
Off cd: Transmutes 1 condition on the Engi every 10 seconds into a boon. Has an internal cd that triggers only upon receiving a condition
Toolbelt: Cleanses 1 condition every 10 seconds from allies.
Activation: Projects a light-field. Transmutes 2 conditions on allies into boons, and 2 boons on enemies into conditions. Lay radiated targets have up to 4 boons transmuted. Consumes lay-radiation
Storm-Core
Off cd: Pulse 5 seconds of fury every 10 seconds on the engi
Toolbelt: Grant a uniqe buff that increases precision on allies by 150
Activation: Stun-breaker. Projects a lightning-field. Daze enemies in 240 range for 2 seconds. Lay-radiated targets get stunned for 1 sec. Consumes lay-radiation.
Force-Core
Off cd: Grant a unique buff to the engi that increases toughness by 150
Toolbelt: Pulses 3sec of protection every 10 seconds to allies
Activation: Projects a light-field. Projects a projectile-destroying bubble centered on the engineer. Lay-radiated targets have their projectiles reflected and are dazed for 1 second. The daze-proc consumes lay-radiation.
Might-Core
Off cd: Grants a unique Buff that increases condition-damage to the engineer by 150
Toolbelt: Stacks 1 might on allies every 5 seconds. Lasts 15 seconds.
Activation: Projects a fire-field. Inflicts 10 Stacks of vulnerability on enemies in a 240 range. Lay-radiated enemies suffer from weakness. Consumes lay-radiation.
Elite:
I'm kinda lost on this one.
Could be either a device that resets core (utility?)-cd's instantly on a 90sec cd, that pulses 3sec of alacrity every 10sec for the engi only, and inflicts slow on ley-radiated targets upon activation.
or:
Magneton-Core
Off cd: Grants 2 Stacks of stability to the engineer every 10 sec
Toolbelt: Grants 1 Stack of Stability to allies every 10 sec
Activation: Stun-Breaker. Unleashes an AoE-Knockback. Inflicts 10 Stacks of confusion on lay-radiated targets. Consumes lay-radiation.
Traits should revolve around improvements on certain Cores on the top-lane, Maze-Improvements on the middle, and lay-radiation at the bottom. After unlocking the weapon, general core traits should revolve around general condi-dmg and survivability.
I'm a huge fan of the heavy weapon idea for a long range spec - like a kit capable of big sustained damage but is slow moving, and can knock over or apply continual cripple and weakness in an AOE cone. Alternatively can used as a good range damage defense class with multiple options for missile destruction and some reflect. new weapon is mainhand mace.
You know you want it ...
https://dviw3bl0enbyw.cloudfront.net/uploads/forum_attachment/file/126473/horrik.jpg
Sparkr's Wonderful World of Engineering - https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCEONFRaJV2u2f12ytXEir9A
I was thinking more along the lines of a gatling gun with suppression style skills... rocket launcher is cool but imo just blends in with the rest of the explosive options too much.