This class had been underperforming for years now and then they go ahead and nerf our earth shield, which was one of the few mitigations we have.
I think I speak for all PvP players when I say Elementalist is the hardest class to play and most difficult to do well in game. As such, players should be rewarded for playing well.
I have thought about a couple of changes that could help progress this sad game state and add some flavor to this meta.
Dragons tooth bugs constantly and just vanishes, also scepter in generally feels weak despite the recent " buffs ".
1. Increase the damage of dragons tooth by about 20%
2. Reduce cooldown of Elemental Celerity by 5 seconds.
3. Increase damage mod of Relentless Fire ( Cata Fire utility ) up from 15% to 25%
I really think these changes would bump Catalyst up to A tier ( down from where it is now D tier ) allowing it to complete with the really strong sidenoders like vindicator and defense warrior.