To begin, I have played GW2 before. I played for maybe 6 months at launch, and then stopped after that. I think I probably entered wvw once or twice then, but honestly I can't remember. Then over the years I'd log in for a few days here and there just to check out the game but never stuck with it for that a few days again. I've started playing again for the most I have since launch and have been playing for a few weeks now.
This is not a complaint. I just think the introduction experience to WvW is very lacking and just wanted to share my experience so that perhaps one day it might be improved.
I was recently reading about all the different ways to get geared, and looking at end game activities and rewards, and that's when I saw WvW get mentioned a lot. I saw that for some legendaries it's necessary. I'd like to start working on a legendary item, so I figured I'd give wvw a shot and learn about it in the process. Trying to figure out how to even get started in WvW left me confused for quite some time. I opened the WvW screen and saw 6 different options. There was no indication what any of them really were beyond a vague description. I saw that three of them were each red, blue and green. So I chose the red one because red means bad guys, right? I'm looking for PvP.
So I enter the map. I'm in some kind of fort and there's a bunch of vendors that are clearly for more progressed players than I. I scan the zone map and see it's very large with no Waypoints, so it's going to be a lot of running it looks like. I find a group of people leaving the base so I follow them. They stop at a smaller base next to ours, we fight a few NPCs and capture it. They all mount up and run off, leaving me in the dust. I can't keep up with them because my mounts don't work here. I make a note to look up why at a later time. I can see their dots on the map for now, so I try to catch up but by the time I find a way to get to them, they're long gone.
I give up trying to follow a group since they're too fast for me to stick with them. I look around, and there's not much around me. No NPCs, no friendly players, no enemy players. Honestly the whole thing felt pretty empty and dead. I find an enemy base and manage to kill the guards, but then I'm downed in about half a second by an enemy player. I was trying to figure out what happened and how I could take them on when... looks like I have to resurrect all the way back at the main base. It took me like five minutes just to run to where I was before, and I really didn't feel like running all the way just to find no one was there.
There was no indication of what to do. I found the participation score which seems to be tied to my rewards, but I struggled to keep it at tier 2 because there was simply nothing I could find to do. Killing NPCs didn't do anything, and I couldn't capture any bases by myself, and I could keep up with the groups who were capturing bases. There were still the 5 other wvw zones that I had no idea what they were for, or how I know which one to go to. Did I just go to the wrong zone? Should I have gone to Green or Blue or one of the ones without colors? How do I know which ones have any people? The game explains none of this, or if it does, I missed it.
I can see how WvW could be fun, and it looks fun in some of the YouTube videos I've seen of people doing it. But all those videos are from a year or so ago. Is WvW just completely dead now? Did I miss all the action? I tried it again a few days later and it was the same. I ran around a giant empty map for 40 minutes and couldn't find anything that seemed like it was worth doing. Anything I did do have no effect on anything or didn't get me any rewards.
But really the thing that irked me the most was that I HAD found a group of people to run with, but because new player mounts don't work in WvW, I couldn't even play with them. Seems weird to artificially segregate new players from experienced ones in that way when this seems like a game mode that requires a group of people. I thought it would playable solo since you can enter solo, but it doesn't feel that way unless you're some kind of PvP god who can take on a group of five by yourself.
Anyway, that's all. I'm going to keep trying to figure it out a few more times and ask around in chat. Some people were helpful, others just told me "maybe wvw isn't for you" when I was just asking how it even works.