So I played a lot of it in PvP and had quite fun, much better than I thought it would be, but it has some glaring issues:
Your dodge isn't a dodge... I actually assumed this was a bug at first and reported it because you still take full damage up until the final 0.5 seconds of the animation where you get an evade. So basically you CC yourself for the first 1 second or so and then get a normal evade at the cost of a dodge that everyone else gets and you are unable to reaction roll... I don't see the point of having this huge one cast dodge if it is an objectively worse dodge.
As far as PvP is concerned, both elites are really underwhelming Spear of Archemorus misses 80% of the time because it is easy to dodge, and has to keep line of sight for the full duration of the cast whilst keeping in the 2000 range of where you first cast it and even when it does it, it hits like a wet noodle. It is imo worse than the 2 skill on a LB power DH, a build that isn't exactly meta. Urn of Saint Viktor just gets you killed if you ever use it in a combat situation so once the spear is on CD you usually have to wait to F2 so you can get spear back as I don't see why you would touch this with a 10ft pole. Or you could spend 4 seconds trying to switch it on your own, which again, will get you killed in combat.
Scavenger Burst and Tree Song take way too long to cast, they are small, low impact AoEs (Tree Song is decently impactful to be fair). The cast time is so long that they often feel not even worth casting because there effect is so little. Trying to hit a moving target with Scavenger Burst is impossible with such a small AoE, imo it should be 1/4 sec cast like herald Elemental Blast. Elemental Blast is more offensively viable imo and a much better AoE (which was mentioned to be this vindicators strength but honestly it it isn't).
The greatsword seems fine, it just feels like ranger greatsword with less CC copy and pasted onto Rev so a little disappointing it has got to be said. Between that and the animations it is unfortunately quite clear that Rev was not given the time and attention the other elite specs received which is again disappointing. But at least I had more fun than I thought I would playing it in PvP and I could see it being somewhat viable there with a few patches
