[GW3 is long overdue]

I was very surprised to see them update the games engine instead of working on gw3

However Anet is a very small team and a smaller team works on gw so unlikely to see anything besides what the few people working on the game now want the game to become, different to how it used to be. 

[Wizard vault destroyed communty feel of the dailies - please fix this]

after quitting and forgetting to login due to them massively nerfing the daily logins we used to get, its interesting to see the current Anet mostly dead dev team still keeping features the majority hates while a small minority on the forums defends the bad design choice 

[upcoming relic... no golemancer... Starting to really dislike this relic system...]

This one being the most interesting to me, that not only did they take something away that we all worked for and spent time on and it had been in the game for a decade, but you can't even earn it back by playing because its out of the game forever. 

Which means without knowing it Runes were FOMO 😄 And new players can never experience the fun we once had with them as they are forced into the Inferior forced in Relics 

[The Weapon Beta is bad and here is why]

The best part about them doing beta's is we know they will ignore all feedback and any testing we do is pointless. 

[They are selling hero points in the gem store now]

So one of the things that made HOT Great, its hard HP's that were a skill check for people or trains setup, can now just be bought past with RL Money. 
Another stab to GW2 amongst all the recent stabs the game has undertaken. The best part about GW2 was that it was different to other MMO's and did things differently. Obviously they don't want that anymore and have not since EoD. Ever since that Expansion launched we've had so many of these changes that no one asked for.... 

At least buying them with WvW currency still required you to actually play the game. What about those people whose ONLY defence of the Wizards Vault is "you have to play the game, wow!" where are they now? 

If I could play a version of this game that's in the state it was the day before EOD released, I would play GW2 for the rest of my life.... It was always meant to be a mmo different to other mmo's. It was never meant to be compared to them. Why are they doing this. 

[Asking for relic of the trapper every day until anet adds it back in to pve/wvw day 1]

2 hours ago, VonSchnitzel.9025 said:

if i must die for my cause than so be it. 

DAY 2

Good luck! Not entirely sure why they decided to introduce these "relics" without it being a complete system that had replacements for all rune effects we currently had. 

They literally took something we had, changed it and then made us have to go get what we already had back and then did not even include all the rune effects anyway. 

Such a bad new system 

[No reason to log in anymore. Daily log in rewards are gone.]

Why did they do this? 

Why fix what is not broken? 

Because dailies could not be monetised? 

[Are we really comfortable paying for unfinished expansions?]

On 11/10/2023 at 5:18 AM, Dopamine.6324 said:

mean guess its pretty fair comparison gw2 to wow, so similar prices
like if you played wow since start, you would have paid upto 4k€ already by just being able to play the game with all latest content

so lets do some math, lets just say each xpac+base game gw2 total 250€.
gw2 = 250€ 11 years
wow = 4000€ 19? years
you tell me which has higher content per € value

This math is not exactly correct, you give a random base amount for GW2 which would be 1,000% incorrect depending on the person and when they started playing GW2. 

Sure you could make the argument that you can technically unlock all the living worlds for in game currency but so can you buy sub time in WoW with in game gold. You could have played and owned WoW for years and have not paid a cent. 

But for example new players, they won't have paid anything near that for either and well the true reason has nothing to do with money but entirely because GW2 has a skeleton crew of devs working on it whereas WoW has a studio. Anet devotes as little as possible to this game. 

[Took a break, where is the dailies and why have my runes be ruined?]

Coming back after a break from the game and for the past decade many things have stayed the same. By the looks of things a bunch of things that were not broken were fixed for no reason. 

Where's Dailies at now? Chest of Loyalty? For the past decade you could quit and come back and nothing would be fomo but this feels like the devs have tried to force it into this game for no reason. Now you are forced to keep doing this new thing to keep up. 

And what on Earth happened to runes and why are Relics so dumb and worse in every way?  

[i knew it. my dungeon runes are ruined]

We said so many times in the thread: 
"Relics are fine and dandy, but only release them when the system is FINISHED" 

Did Anet listen? Of course not. Why design something to completion when you can half bake it and release it then with many features missing while also forgetting that legendary items exist? 

[How the new daily system in Wizards Vault reduced my enjoyment of GW2 [Merged]]

Don't fix what aint broke

Anet: 

Instructions unclear, got new system no one asked for caught online while pressing the backspace key on old systems that had been in game for decades. 

[Has the GW2 design philosophy changed?]

Its sad this. I mean I had quit again now due to SOTO and all these changes that no one asked for as they ignored pages upon pages of feedback while they patted themselves on the back as the game progressively dies. I mean you can tell the difference from where they are doing things right or wrong just based on the server size counts. For years they had been reducing the size of the wvw servers, and the first time in years during the Return to event they had to increase the size of the servers as they were all full. I remember when there was only 2 options to choose from not labelled full. 

Since then? Only a handful of full with them reducing them again. With "alliances" promised to be delivered years ago that supposedly to end this anyway as updates changed wvw to compensate for the alliances they never delivered as wvw was in a terrible state till the recent change... ONLY if you no lifed wvw and could camp out the final chest now. 

The game was on such a high with pof and lw4, if they kept that momentum going there would be so many thousands more people playing gw2 right now. If they stayed with their design philosophies there would be so much more people playing. This Wizard Vault has already cost the game players. It doesn't matter if you as an individual like it or defend it when people are quitting over it. It means it was a bad design choice they put in on purpose while listening to no feedback. Whose replacing all the people that are quitting as you cheer for these people to quit because they want the game to improve and be in a better state as they know it could have been? 

As soon as we start to see people compare GW2 to other mmo's, they have gone too far. And we've been seeing that with every announcement around SOTO. GW2 made a name for itself by being a different mmo unlike any other. If it becomes just like other mmo's, the many hundreds of mmo's that have died and gone forever, what exactly was the point of sending gw2 down that a path? 
A good game does not need people defending it on the forums or other social media sites (That are not moderated with bias and use censorship tactics), people know its good. Word of mouth always is stronger then what you read online. Physical evidence is stronger then any defending forum post tactic. 

I defended GW2 originally by just telling people to give the game a go because its not what they think it is. GW2 keeps this path, it will become what they think it is. 

[I demand my Inquest Mark I Golem back]

On 8/25/2023 at 7:11 AM, Darves.6798 said:

You took my companion Inquest Mark I Golem from me. Now the game is even more difficult than before. I got used to him, he helped me in the game. He was like a tank, he took aggro from the mobs and I could stand back and shoot the guns. Now he's gone and I'm dying all the time because all the mobs are attacking me. You made the game unplayable for me. Not only did you weaken my character's gear, but you also took my companion. Your worthless relics are supposed to be compensation? I demand the return of my golem companion.

P.S. To other players, especially tryhards, I do not wish to be insulted in any way in the comments. Any rude reference to me in a comment will be reported as harassment.

 

Imagine trying to fix something that was never broken in the first place that has worked in game since its launch over a decade ago. 

Why did Anet do this? No one was asking for this. Runes was not a broken system it was a system that worked flawlessly with no bugs that everyone relied on. 
It just, doesn't make any sense to me why they thought Relics would go down well when they were fixing a system that was not broken. 

[Someone sell me on this new expansion]

On 8/25/2023 at 11:59 AM, Razor.6392 said:

Yes, I 've read the overview post a few weeks ago, mostly skimmed through it, and based on the perspective from a day 1 gw2 headstart player, this is what I know so far:

1. New story: Now that the dragons are dead, we focusing on side stories, this time starring Zojja.
2. Wizard tower (I thought that was located in base tyria?) or something is the main focus.
3. There's a new UI icon for this tower next to the trading post and all of that stuff, most of the rewards are locked for non SotO owners.
4. New maps, not sure how many.
5. Relic system to help diversify armor runes (so far seems to be doing the exact opposite).
6. Daily system destroyed.
7. No new specializations because ANet's creativity has reached its limit (paraphrasing what that post said). Instead they're going to remove the weapon exclusivity for existing specs.
8. No new mounts (correct me if I'm wrong).
9. No new pvp or wvw content.
10. No completely new system (HoT had gliding, PoF had mounts and even though EoD had garbage fishing, it was something at least).
11. BONUS! Goes without saying but no new classes, races or anything of the sort.

What exactly is worth $25 in all of this? Isn't it just standard living world + relics and other changes nobody asked for?

I already skipped EoD because it didn't deserve to be called an expansion (mainly due to lacking in #9 and #10), why is this $25? Do your best effort in convincing me to buy it!

It does at least give us a reason as to why EoD didn't have any class based runes, they were most likely planning this relic system for awhile (which makes the fact that it released half baked in a beta state to the live game even funnier). I had at the time only bought EoD cause I was hoping to get more story like we got with lw4, I should have realised what we'd actually get. 

I mean experiencing EoD made me quit the game so going by that, I'd stay away from anything flagged with the expansion tag line. PoF set such a high precedent, guess it was truly impossible for them to give us anything close to that, ever again. 

[SotO Is so good and People need to stop complaining]

This thread title though. Imagine if the world worked like one single person liking something so somehow no one is allowed to dislike it. 

"stop complaining" like its somehow a demand for people to stop having an opinion that differs. Like we not allowed to be individuals. 

[Am I the only one not enjoying this expansion?]

On 8/23/2023 at 6:47 PM, GingeraleDragon.5804 said:

I had a sinking feeling upon logging in today that there really was no leadup to this expansion. No big trailer, no promotional period, no obvious open plot thread in-game. Upon starting the story, I'm given fetch quests on maps I've already been on, only to be treated with a slog of a prologue instance, then patronized as if this weren't a ten-year-old game and we've been doing this sort of stuff for that long. Upon completing the first chapter, I'm thrown into the first map of a new paid expansion that's made up entirely of reused assets from other maps that I've spent countless hours on. I get the context, but as a first impression, it's not a great one.

I began having my doubts with it once I thought about how good End of Dragons was. And my doubts turned out to be just how I felt. I mentally checked out and closed the game when they told me to learn about skyscales. The same skyscales I grinded out PvP and maps for currencies to get, the same skyscales the Commander themself witnessed coming into the world, the same skyscales I've been riding for like a year now.

It's pretty obvious the writing team got fired again, but this one couldn't even be bothered to do more than skim whatever recap they were given. The characters treat the Commander like some new guy, some rookie who hasn't fought like 3 different wars and killed six elder dragons. If this was placed before Heart of Thorns, it would make sense, but it isn't. This doesn't feel like a Guild Wars expansion, this feels like a completely different game, but there's charr in it. I can look over a lot of flaws with the way this game handles keeping players busy, but when you're asking me to grind out a mastery on what is essentially a map that's just maps I've seen before but smaller snippets of them, it feels like a dishonest slap in the face. That's not even bringing up how the expansion isn't even finished yet. I couldn't shake the feeling of "This feels like Metal Gear Survive" while playing before I just logged out.

 

If this is the new standard of quality for expansions, I'm really worried about the future of Guild Wars 2, and if half-baked maps, overly long and fairly boring instanced content, and patronizing and confusing dialogue is what we have to look forward to, I won't be pre-ordering the next expansion.

 

This is just disappointing.

I miss being the pact commander, in charge of armies and life or death choices, good times, good writing staff we used to have, I love the games story (though LW3 was still weird) PoF was Freaking amazing and LW4 delivered, IBS could have been good if it led to anywhere and then.... Yeah, we basically a tourist that is now an accountant doing papers at a desk as we sit and read a story. RIP Blish, you were the last well written character death. 

Its high time to quit again, i've quit GW2 for six years before and came back and picked up right where I left off, but with Anet's new design choice, that's not possible anymore. I may Return to do another story run from start to LW4 finish but the game will never be as good as it could have been, which is the true shame. They could have made this game one of the greatest of all time, but Anet by choice has made it not. 

[They ruined the game]

On 8/23/2023 at 5:07 AM, Kaibamon.7206 said:

They removed daily login rewards which was a reason for many to login and surprisingly play a bit after only to replace it with a FOMO Battlepass! They removed much of the rune effects that were ok for a poor relic set. And they removed the reason for specializations since now everyone can use spec weapons.Not to mention the expansion itself is not even complete!. I have huuuge buyers remorse with this expansion. I loved my golemancy rune with my additional golem, why did they have to remove it? I regret buying this expansion and these new changes. anyone else feel the same?

I find it rather hilarious that GW2 was onto a winning formula back during PoF/LW4 times, but instead of keeping it up the studio downsized and we got a rushed IBS so they could do a rushed EoD to lead into a rushed SoTO and other system changes. 

IF the game got no expansions since IBS and instead we got a full IBS we should have gotten, even with nothing else happening, including no pretend Wvw update for alliances as every update to wvw has only made it worse since the alliance "update" beta cough and no pvp updates anyway to talk about the game would have more players and they would be earning thousands more dollars. 

Instead they have chosen to make bad expansions and bad system changes to their winning formula they already had. It doesn't make any sense. If I could play a version of GW2 that ended at LW4 or maybe IBS Drizzlewood with no story (as it was terrible after how EPIC lw4 story was) I could play that GW2 for years and it would be more popular in those zones as it wouldn't have the almost always dead cantha failed expansion zones staining the game. Everything they have done since EOD launched has made people leave and they keep ruining their own game. Then Anet says thanks to all the people still giving them money ignoring all feedback, gotta love that. 

[Updraft and Leyline break Griffon Flight [Merged]]

On 8/24/2023 at 11:43 AM, Tuna Bandit.3786 said:

Why am I not suprised, I hate the leyline mastery on Griffon.

You are pulled, no matter what... no matter angle you hit it, no matter speed you hit it... ley lines now are litterly roadblocks for fun flight paths.

They did not listen.

I am not happy. Some maps are now no longer fun on a Griffon.

Please ArenaNet, let the interaction with leyline and/or updrafts be OPTIONAL with an action key... "press to ride the line" 

But your obsession of automation DOWNGRADED the flying experience. 

I want to ride my Griffon, not be taken on a ride.

Some of the games best content is watching those Griffon riders pull off amazing stunts to show off the games world. 

Imagine taking that away from GW2 or hindering it in some way 😞 Really hope they fix this at least, not that they listen to feedback. 

[Wizard vault's weekly wvw defense events, like, why...?]

22 hours ago, Zephyrus.9680 said:

I have thousands of hours in WvW and still don't even know the multiple triggers required getting credit on defense. It's something like: 

1: objective was contested (has an X)

2: some form of participation like killing an opposing player or siege(?) while near(?)/inside(?) the objective. Though repairing walls no longer works after they changed that a couple years ago. 

3: you are in the zone when the defense timer hits 0 (?). Not even sure on this but there are so many instances not getting credit I assume this is a condition. 

So all 3 conditions must be true to get credit. It's maybe not as bad as veteran creature slayer from the old system but it's not at all intuitive and more importantly, normal gameplay in WvW will usually miss it. They should just remove that from the daily and particularly weekly rotations. 

It used to be a lot better before they continued to make wvw worse. if a wall was under attack, you could repair it and it would give you contribution, then when the timer ticked, that would count as you defending, no matter where on the map you were. But we can't have good wvw anymore. 

[Fix the WvW defense event]

They did all these updates and changes (Making wvw worse in every single way) because alliances was supposed to fix it, it was in prep for alliances. Just like them removing the Outnumbered pips cause they were like "but alliances". 

2 years later. WvW is still in a worse state and no alliances. 

[Secrets of the Obscure Launch Week: Thank you!]

Everyone's complaining cept paid for positive account bots on the forums yet somehow at least if the zones didn't launch dead like EOD did which launched day 1 with dead zones at least that's a plus for sure! 

Oh to have a version of GW2 to play that ended when the story ended, LW4. 

[Relics will reduce build diversity]

Rest in peace Undead Runes, you were loved while you lasted 

[RIP My Runes]

22 hours ago, Areohtwo.7839 said:

My golem is gone, my heal on kill vamp rune is gone.  They could have waited until they had all the rune affects done before taking them away and giving me NADA.  Nothing. Thanks for  you money, Now we take what you already had! Pfft

This is the true kitten thing, because instead of releasing relics how they SHOULD have released, ya know, finished and fleshed out feature, they released them half baked with many things missing and no legendary variant. 

[PvP and WvW Reward Potions Update]

Frick me I was not expecting this. 

This is just hilariously terrible I'm just. What? 

[For inactive players, is there any point in logging in any more?]

On 8/23/2023 at 4:23 AM, Stx.4857 said:

Now you have to play the game to get rewards.  A bit of a shock to some, but it’s a good thing.  
 

Logging in every day still makes you an active player by the way. 

This is such a bad concept, Arguments like this just prove that people don't want the game to be alive and want it to die. I can tell this person wants GW2 to shut down and the servers turned off. 

Ignoring what people are saying and just stating your own opinion helps noone.