that we wouldn't just play the recycled content, but actually getting to play stories that happened off screen, that we found out about it in Season 2 - I'm talking about Scarlet seeing the vision of the All, Omadd's death etc. More diving into this character, what happened after the visions of Caithe's past, when Secondborn awoke (Seeds of Truth instance).
Everybody that cares about the story knows about her madness, but I'd love to see and interact with Scarlet before the vision of Eternal Alchemy.
That would actually be something so unique to see all the character's background stories, not just witnessing how Taimi appeared in the story out of nowhere - knowing her life as a progeny and interactions with Zojja etc. That would be a unique Season 1 experience, not replaying few episodes that were shorter than Season 2 ones.
The oldest and strongest emotion of mankind is fear, and the oldest and strongest kind of fear is fear of the unknown.
H. P. Lovecraft